P-ISSN: 2808-0467
E-ISSN: 2808-5051
Homepage: https://iss.internationaljournallabs.com/index.php/iss
543 This work is licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0
ANALYZING THE STRUCTURE-CONDUCT-PERFORMANCE OF
THE TOFU INDUSTRY IN BANDA ACEH
Putra Fisabilillah Lubis
1
, Romano
2
, Muhammad Rusdi
3
Syiah Kuala University, Indonesia
1
putralbs@mhs.unsyiah.ac.id
2
romanos_agri@unsyiah.ac.id
3
emrusdi@unsyiah.ac.id
PAPER INFO ABSTRACT
Received:
December 2022
Revised:
February 2022
Approved:
February 2022
Background: At this time the food industry sector is growing very rapidly
and increasing fierce competition among business people such as the tofu
industry in Banda Aceh City. This encourages the importance of the
application of SCP in describing the overall state of the market both the
structure, behavior, and performance resulting from industry.
Aim: This research aims to describe the structure, behavior, and performance
of the industry as well as the influence of these three dimensions on the tofu
industry in Banda Aceh City.
Method: This study uses a quantitative approach and uses a census method
where the population is all tofu producers registered with the Banda Aceh
City Labor Office in the industrial section of 2019-2020 which amounted to
13 industries. CR4 and IHI analysis is used to measure structure, CLR
analysis is applied to measure behavior, and PCM is used to improve the
performance of the tofu industry in Banda Aceh City. The effect test on 3
dimensions is measured using Path Analysis.
Findings: Found CR4 values 36.43 percent, IHI 729.99 points, CLR 11.06
percent, and PCM 12.08 percent. As well as found the relationship of variable
MS to PCM positive and significant, clr relationship to positive PCM is not
significant and the relationship of MS to PCM through positive CLR is not
significant.
KEYWORDS
tofu industry, competition, SCP, path analysis
INTRODUCTION
At this time the food industry sector is growing very rapidly and increasingly fierce
competition among business actors. This opens the opportunity for healthy and unhealthy
competition such as the presence of a monopoly market structure controlled by certain
companies (Zulfi, 2015).
The market structure will encourage business people to take varied strategic decisions in
the face of competition, this is often referred to as corporate behavior. Behavior in competition
can be reflected in pricing strategies, advertising strategies, production strategies, enterprise
integration, as well as research and development (Mankiw, 2018). Determination of the right
competition strategy will affect the growth and sustainability of a business. Therefore, the
market structure will affect the company's behavior in policymaking that will determine the
company's performance both in terms of profit and business sustainability (Shabastian, 2013).
This is a driver of the importance of understanding the market structure by every business
actor in improving the performance of his company (Raider, 1998). To that end, the Structure-
Conduct-Performance (SCP) paradigm can be applied in describing the overall state of the
market both the structure, behavior, and performance resulting from industry. This SCP
paradigm can be used in every industry such as the food industry that continues to grow over
time (Rekarti, 2016). Many food industries have very good prospects and continue to grow in
Analyzing the Structure-Conduct-Performance of the Tofu Industry in Banda Aceh
544 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(5), Feb 2022
Banda Aceh City. One of the food industries that continues to grow is the tofu industry
produced by small and medium-sized industrial enterprises (SMEs) where the consumption of
tofu for the last 10 years shows the growth that can be seen in Figure 1.
Figure 1. Average Per Capita Tofu Consumption Every Year, 2009-2019 (Source: BPS,
2020)
One of the food industries that continues to grow in Banda Aceh city is the tofu industry
which has a positive growth trend at the level of per capita consumption. In general, the tofu
manufacturing business is a household industry that is in high demand by consumers both from
the upper class to the lower class. Given the promising market segment conditions as well as
the magnitude of consumer spending, the possibility of industry growth will continue to
increase. This has a positive effect on the development of the tofu industry itself, but also
industry businesses know will be faced with intense competition that continues to increase
between competitors, either those who have been in the market or who want to enter the tofu
industry market in Banda Aceh City. (BPS, 2020)(Ambara, Ustriyana, & Rantau, 2017)
The success or absence of strategies and behaviors implemented by every business
person knows in the face of market competition can be seen from the resulting performance.
The level of profit or loss of the company is one of the measurements that are often used to
assess the results of a company's performance. The higher the added value, the efficiency of
industrial performance is increasing so that the profits obtained will be greater (Canh, 2019).
On this basis, this research is aimed at reviewing how the structure, behavior, and
performance of the tofu industry in Banda Aceh as well as the structural relationship, behavior,
and performance of the tofu industry in Banda Aceh through the Structure-conduct-
Performance paradigm using industry tofu market data.
Define the Structure Conduct Performance Paradigm
The framework for knowing the causes and effects of why marketing systems run unfairly
(Adil) and inefficiently is done through a structure, behavior, and market appearance approach
(S-C-P approach). The approach is based on three interrelated things, namely, the way
0.1
0.11
0.12
0.13
0.14
0.15
0.16
0.17
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Average consumption of tofu
(kg/capita)
Year
Analyzing the Structure-Conduct-Performance of the Tofu Industry in Banda Aceh
545 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(5), Feb 2022
companies organize in a market (Structure), telling as a whole how they make decisions
(Behavior), which in turn will change the level of efficiency and fairness (Justice) that occurs
in the market (Appearance) (Seperich, 1994).
This SCP approach is done to oversee competition between companies in various markets,
how the company performs actions due to running not by expectations, it will have an impact
on the fairness and efficiency of the marketing system. In the SCP model, it is often noted how
the structure of the market affects market behavior and then how behavior affects the
appearance of the market. In addition, in various studies often the relationship between
structure-behavior or behavior-appearance can affect each other or there is a causal relationship
(Anindita, 2004).
Market Structure
Market structure is an organizational characteristic that determines the relationship
between various sellers in the market, between various buyers in the market, between sellers
and buyers, and between sellers who control the market with the power of other suppliers of
goods, including the strength of new companies that may enter the market. In other words, the
market structure addresses the organizational characteristics of a market that affect the level of
competition and pricing in the market. Through the market, the structure will be known whether
a market will lead to having a perfect competition structure (Perfect market) or imperfect
competition (Imperfect market).
There are several criteria for determining market structure: a) Concentration level of
buyers and sellers, b) Level of product differentiation, c) Conditions for market entry (barriers
to entry), d) Level of market knowledge, e) Level of integration and diversification. Kotler
(2008) explained that the number of sellers and buyers, product differentiation, barriers to
entry, cost structure, vertical integration, and conglomeration levels form the basis for the
formation of competitive market structures in the industry. The number of sellers and buyers
relates to bargaining positions between sellers, buyers, or between buyers and sellers.
Market concentration, also often referred to as industrial concentration, refers to the extent
to which the market share of the largest company in a market (Industry) accounts for most of
the economic activity such as sales, assets, or jobs (Koch, 1980). The rationale underlying
industrial measurement or market concentration is the economic theory of industrial
organizations that states that, other things. In other words, high market concentration is more
conducive for companies engaging in monopolistic practices that lead to resource misallocation
and poor economic performance. Market concentration in this context is used as one of the
indicators of market strength (OECD, 2003). Increased market concentration leads to decreased
competition and efficiency and increases market forces (Hall & Tideman, 1967).
Market Conduct
Market behavior refers to a pattern of corporate behavior that indicates how to adopt or
adapt to a market in which they act as sellers or buyers. Market behavior is an interaction of
the behavior of various companies, which include: their strategies, tactics, and practices.
Market behavior is the behavior of a company in changes in price, output, product
characteristics, sales costs, and research costs (Bain, 1959).
Analyzing the Structure-Conduct-Performance of the Tofu Industry in Banda Aceh
546 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(5), Feb 2022
Analyzing corporate behavior is usually measured through variable capital-to-labor ratio
(CLR). The Capital-Labour Ratio is used to look at production techniques used in industry.
The greater the value of the Capital-Labour Ratio, the greater the value of expenditure for
capital costs, the greater the industry tends to be capital intensive. Vice versa, if the capital-
labor ratio is small, it means that spending on labor is getting bigger, then the industry tends to
be labor-intensive.
Market Performance
Performance is the result of work that is influenced by the structure and behavior of the
industry where the usual results are identified with the amount of market control or the
magnitude of a company's profits in an industry. In more detail, performance can also be
reflected through efficiency, growth (including market expansion), employment opportunities,
professional prestige, personnel welfare, and group pride (Kotler, 2008).
Performance is the result of work that is influenced by the structure and behavior of the
industry where the results are usually seen from the magnitude of market control or the number
of profits of a company in an industry (Rajapathirana & Hui, 2018). Performance in an industry
can be observed through added value, productivity, and efficiency. Value added is the
difference between the input value and the output value. Productivity is the result achieved per
labor or unit of production factor within a certain period of time. Efficiency is a comparison of
how much a company can benefit from a variable to get as much output. One calculation that
can be used in measuring performance is Price Cost Margin (PCM). In theory, PCM in the
context of a dominant firm (Imperfect market competition) is derived from the equation of
profit maximization, so the Lerner Index equation is obtained, where PCM is the ratio of profit
to total income (Lipczynski, Goddard, & Wilson, 2017).
Definisi Path Analysis
Path Analysis is one of the most popular multivariate analysis techniques. Path Analysis
was developed in 1918 by Sewall Wright. Wright, a geneticist, wrote in the 1920s popularizing
this now widely applied statistic as an approach to research efforts (Crossman, 2020). Path
analysis can be viewed from a variety of perspectives. This is a way to sort out colinearity
patterns between predictors and criterion variables. This approach tends to determine whether
the pattern of colinearity relationships is temporal or causal.
Path Analysis is best illustrated and understood through path diagrams. A path diagram is
simply a diagram in which an arrow is drawn from a variable to another variable that is
considered to have an influence. Variable names can be represented by numbers written in
squares, rectangles, or oval shapes. A very interesting feature of the path analysis diagram is
that the position of the variable can be changed or changed and the interactive effect checked.
This is why different models can be generated from the same set of variables. And even new
variables can be incorporated into an existing model or some variable removed from it.
These possibilities make no sense if it sticks to the traditional meaning of the terms
independent and dependent variables or predictor variables and criteria as used in correlational
statistics and regressions (Fidelis & Sunday, 2018).
Analyzing the Structure-Conduct-Performance of the Tofu Industry in Banda Aceh
547 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(5), Feb 2022
METHOD
This research will be conducted in Banda Aceh City. The research will be conducted in
March 2021. The scope of this research is limited to tofu industry activities in Banda Aceh City
ranging from production to tofu marketing in Banda Aceh City. The objects used in this study
are the tofu industry as well as market participants in the tofu industry in Banda Aceh City.
This study uses a quantitative approach and uses a census method where the population is all
tofu producers registered with the Banda Aceh City Labor Office in the industrial section of
2019-2020 which amounted to 13 tofu industries. In this study, we used two types of data
retrieval methods, primary data, and secondary data. Primary data collection is done by
interviewing the manufacturer. Secondary data is collected from a variety of sources, such as
government agencies, reports, newsletters, and websites.
Analysis of Concentration Ratio Four (CR4)
In CR4 Analysis required preliminary data i.e. Market Share of every company knows.
For this reason, market share measurements are taken using the following equations:
MSi = Pi/TP X 100%
Where MSi is the Market Share of company i, Pi is the total production absorbed by the
market in company i, and TPi is the total production of all companies absorbed by the market.
Once known market share every company knows, mada can be continued with the equation of
Concentration Ratio Four (CR4) as follows:
CR4 = MS1 + MS2 + MS3 + MS4
Where: CR4 is the concentration ratio of the four largest companies, MS is the market
share of traders. The criteria: 1. CR4 < 0.4 then the market structure is perfect competition
(Competitive) or monopolistic competition (monopolistic Persaingan needs to be seen whether
there is product differentiation or not) 2. 0.4 < CR4 < 0.8 then the market structure is
oligopoly/oligopsony (Often when the CR4 value is above 60-80% is called a tight oligopoly
and the CR4 value is above 40-60% called a loose oligopoly. Although this meaning is often
unclear because measuring the strength of oligopoly/monopoly can be tested through the
strength of market power but discussed at an advanced level. 3. CR4 > 0.8 then the market
structure tends to be monopoly/monopsony. Note: if CR4 < 0.4 then the market structure can
be perfectly competitive and can also include monopolistic, which determines the level of
differentiation of the product.
Analysis of Hirschman Herfindahl Index (HHI)
The equation of the Herfindahl Index is as follows:
IHH = (S1)2 + (S2)2 + .... + (Sec)2
In which IHH: Hirschman Herfindahl Index n: The number of traders in a market area of
Si products: Share of commodity purchases from the ist trader (i = 1,2,3,...,n). The criteria: An
index of less than 1,500 is considered a competitive market, an index between 1,500 to 2,500
Analyzing the Structure-Conduct-Performance of the Tofu Industry in Banda Aceh
548 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(5), Feb 2022
is considered a moderately concentrated market, an index of more than 2,500 or greater is
considered a highly concentrated market (Kvålseth, 2018).
Analysis of Capital-Labour Ratio (CLR)
The data required for behavioral variables consists of behavioral data for the company.
Capital-Labour Ratio is a comparison between the share of a company's expenditure for capital
(capital cost) and the share of corporate expenditure for labor (Labour cost) to calculate
behavioral indicators using Equation 3. This is in line with previous research such as Nzima
(2015). The behavioral equations used are as follows:
CLR = (Capital Cost)/(Labor Costs) X 100%
Information:
Capital Cost = Cost incurred for production (Rp)
Labor Costs = Costs used for labor wages (Rp)
Analysis of Price Cost Margin (PCM)
PCM is a percentage of the profit from the excess receipt of direct costs. The higher the
added value, the efficiency of industrial performance is increasing so that the profits obtained
will be greater (Urata, 1979). The performance equation used is as follows:
PCM = (Added Value)/(Output Value) X 100%
Information:
Added Value = Difference between output values, other inputs and raw materials
Output Value = Value set for per product
Analysis of the added value of agroindustrial tofu products using the Hayami method.
According to Hayami, there are two ways to calculate added value: added value for processing
and added value for marketing.
Path Analysis
The data analysis used in this study is path analysis by utilizing the help of the LISREL
(Linear Structural Relationship) computer program version 8.8. Path analysis was chosen
because in the research model (figure below) there is an intervening variable, namely, Conduct
which moderates the relationship between partnership and Structure with Performance. Indirect
relationships (Indirect effect) will be more difficult to analyze if using multiple regression
analysis.
Analyzing the Structure-Conduct-Performance of the Tofu Industry in Banda Aceh
549 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(5), Feb 2022
Figure 2. Model Diagram path analysis SCP
Based on the image above each P value describes the path and path coefficient between
the variables. From the path diagram above also obtained the structural equation that there are
two regression tests as follows:
a) Direct influence: Z = a + p3X
b) Direct influence: Z = a + p2Y
b) Indirect influence: Z = a +p1X + p2Y
Description: Z: Dependent variables namely PCM, Y: Intervening variables are CLR, a:
Constant coefficient, X: Independent variable i.e. MS, P1: Path coefficient from MS to PCM
Through CLR, P2: Path coefficient from CLR to PCM, P3: Path coefficient from MS to PCM.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The respondents in this study were the owners of each factory. Of the 13 questionnaires
given to each plant, the entire kuesioner is well and complete so that no re-deployment is
required. The response rate of this questionnaire is very high, reaching 100%. In marketing
activities, it is known that the tofu industry in the city of Banda Aceh prioritizes the distribution
of its products to traditional markets.
Descriptive research on industry characteristics will not be included in the data processing
process. These data are only used as supporting data to provide additional justification for
research results.
The Structure of the Tofu Industry
The tofu industrial market in Banda Aceh City is a type of competitive market that is
characteristically perfect. This is also reinforced from the measurement of market structure
involving the market share of every tofu company in Banda Aceh City. It was found that no
company controlled a market share exceeding 10%, this state of state indicates an even market
mastery between tofu companies in Banda Aceh City. The company with the highest market
share is controlled by Tahu Solo company at 9.98%, while the lowest is controlled by Khadijah
company at 5.70%. This can be seen in Table 1.
Analyzing the Structure-Conduct-Performance of the Tofu Industry in Banda Aceh
550 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(5), Feb 2022
Table 1. Market Share, CR4, HHI Tofu Industry in Banda Aceh City
No
Company
Name
Production per
month
CR4
(%)
HHI
Sum
Unit
1
Tofu Solo
5.600
Board
9,98
37,43
99,64
2
Tofu Abi
5.400
Board
9,63
92,65
3
Tofu Sumedang
5.200
Board
9,27
85,92
4
Tofu Aceh
4.800
Board
8,56
73,21
5
Wahidin
4.600
Board
8,20
67,23
6
Meurah Jaya
4.500
Board
8,02
64,34
7
Tofu
4.200
Board
7,49
56,05
8
MKS
4.200
Board
7,49
56,05
9
Abdul Kadir
3.900
Board
6,95
48,33
10
Mandiri Tahu
3.700
Board
6,60
43,50
11
Two Brothers
3.500
Board
6,24
38,92
12
Tjinj Jay Moy
3.300
Board
5,88
34,60
13
Khadijah
3.200
Board
5,70
32,54
Total
13
56.100
Board
100
792,99
Four companies that control the largest market share are Tahu Solo, Tahu Abi, Tahu
Sumedang, Tahu Aceh. The four largest tofu company market shares totaled 37.43 percent, this
shows the type of tofu industry market that is formed is a type of perfect competition market
based on cr4 method criteria. Each company that is then summed up for the determination of
the type of market of the industry knows based on the IHI method. The sum result was obtained
points of 792.99. The achievement of this point shows that the tofu industrial market in Banda
Aceh city is not concentrated or perfectly competitive.
The perfect competition that occurs in the industry knows very profitable when viewed on
the consumer side. This is due to the price formed from the minimum average cost so that the
perfect competition market guarantees the production of goods or products at the lowest cost.
As for producers knowing the type of market perfect competition will encourage producers to
focus on the quality of production and market share development.
Tofu Industry Behavior
The aspect used to capture the behavioral patterns applied by companies to know in
adapting to market situations is with labor strategies. Not all companies with large capital costs
incur costs for large labor as well. This applies the same as companies with small capital costs
out for small labor. As can be seen in Meurah Jaya companies that incur lower working costs
than Khadijah companies where Meurah Jaya company has a Capital-Labour Ratio of only
10.29% while Khadijah company reaches 10.87%. This can be seen in Figure 3.
Analyzing the Structure-Conduct-Performance of the Tofu Industry in Banda Aceh
551 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(5), Feb 2022
Figure 3. Capital-Labour Ratio of Tofu Industry in Banda Aceh City 2019-2020
Capital-Labour Ratio’s value of every company knows in the city of Banda Aceh. Tahu
Sumedang company is seen to have the highest labor costs among the 13 Tofu Solo companies
with a cost of Rp.24,030,000, while the company with the smallest labor costs is incurred by
the Company Tahu Tjinj Jay Moy at a cost of Rp.10,025,000. It was found that the highest
capital costs among the 13 companies were incurred by Tahu Solo company at a cost of
Rp.194,030,000, while the lowest capital cost was incurred by Tahu Tjinj Jay Moy company
amounting to Rp.93,515,000.
From the results of calculations, obtained the Capital-Labour Ratio of each company.
Where the capital-labor ratio of Tahu Solo company is highest with achievement of 12.38
percent and the lowest worth of 10.12 percent achieved by The Tahu Wahidin company. On
average, the tofu industry in Banda Aceh City spends a capital cost of Rp.140,724,000 and the
cost for labor is Rp.15,072,000. This can be interpreted that in general, industrial entrepreneurs
know in Banda Aceh city spends 11.06% of the total costs incurred in production activities.
Industry Performance of Tofu
Advantages are indicators that can be used to analyze the performance of the tuna industry.
However, generally, data on profits at the corporate level is not published. PCM is the value of
profits derived from the excess acceptance of an industry for the cost of products.
In the tofu industry in the city of Banda Aceh, companies that set high output values will
not necessarily get added value or high net profits. It can be seen in Wahidin companies that
have an output value of Rp.42,000 but get a lower added value from Tahu Abi company which
sets its output value at Rp.40,000. Wahidin company only gets a profit of Rp.5,072 per board
or 12.98% of its output value, while Tahu Solo company gets a profit of Rp.5,390 per board or
13.48%. This can be seen in Figure 4.
0%
2%
4%
6%
8%
10%
12%
14%
0
50
100
150
200
250
CLR
Labor/Capital Cost
(000000)
Biaya Tenaga Kerja Biaya Modal CLR
Analyzing the Structure-Conduct-Performance of the Tofu Industry in Banda Aceh
552 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(5), Feb 2022
Figure 4. Price Cost Margin Industry Tahu in Banda Aceh City 2019-2020
Nilai PCM every industry knows who is in the city of Banda Aceh. The highest PCM value
was obtained by Tahu Solo company with a value of 13.85 percent or from the selling price of
tofu per board which was priced at Rp.40,000 and earned a profit of Rp.5,539.6. While the
company knows with the lowest PCM value owned by Dua Saudara worth 10.92 percent or
from the selling price of tofu per board which is priced at Rp.45,000 and earned a profit of Rp.
4,915.
On average, the tofu industry in Banda Aceh City set an output value of Rp. 42000 and
received an added value of Rp.5062.8. It is also seen that the average value of price-cost margin
of the company to know in Banda Aceh city is 12.08%. This can be interpreted that in general
industry entrepreneurs know in Banda Aceh city get 12.08% profit from each tofu sale per
board.
Direct Influence Test
In Appendix 9 can be found the path coefficient value achieved by the Market Share
variable against Price Cost Margin of 0.471 with a calculated T value of 4.116 which is greater
than the value of T table 1.96. From these values, it can be concluded that the hypothesis is
acceptable where the Market Share (Structure) variable has a positive and significant effect
directly on price-cost margin (performance). It can also be interpreted the higher the Market
Share, the higher the Price Cost Margin.
The path coefficient value achieved by the Capital-Labour Ratio variable to the Price Cost
Margin of 0.329 with a calculated T value of 4.101 which is greater than the table T value of
1.96. From these values, it can be concluded that the hypothesis is rejected where the variable
Capital-Labour Ratio (Conduct) has a positive but not significant effect directly on price-cost
margin (performance). The R-Square value achieved on the test was 0.782, it can be concluded
that the impact of Structure and Conduct simultaneously on Performance was 78.2 percent. The
remaining 21.8 percent was affected by other factors. In other words, performance variability
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
PCM
Output/Add Value
(000)
Nilai Output (Rp.) Nilai Tambah (Rp.) PCM (%)
Analyzing the Structure-Conduct-Performance of the Tofu Industry in Banda Aceh
553 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(5), Feb 2022
that can be explained using structure and conduct variables is 78.2 percent, while the effect of
21.8 percent is caused by other variables outside the model.
Indirect Influence Test
To measure the path coefficient on the Market Share variable against Price Cost Margin
through the Capital-Labour Ratio variable, a multiplication between the values P1 and P2 has
been obtained. The P1 and P2 values that have been found respectively are 0.471 and 0.130.
After the multiplication action, the value of the influence of the Market Share variable on Price
Cost Margin through the Capital-Labour Ratio variable of 0.097 or 9.7 percent.
In addition, the Sobel test was also conducted in this study as a test of the significance of
the indirect influence on structure variables on performance through conduct variables. The
value of Z Sobel obtained is 0.62 or less than 1.812 which means that structure to performance
through conduct variables has a positive but insignificant effect. From these values, it can be
concluded that the Hypothesis is rejected where the Market Share (Structure) variable through
the Capital-Labour Ratio (Conduct) has a positive but not insignificant effect indirectly on
Price Cost Margin (Performance).
CONCLUSION
The competition that occurs in the tofu industry in Banda Aceh city runs very fairly where
the tofu industry in Banda Aceh city has a perfect competition structure with a concentration
ratio of 4 reaching 37.43 percent, and Hirschman Herfindahl index concentration level reaching
792.99 points. Conduct applied to the tofu industry in Banda Aceh City showed the allocation
of costs to labor on average amounted to 11.06 percent of the overall cost. Performance industry
entrepreneurs know in Banda Aceh city on average reached 12.08 percent profit from each tofu
sale per board. It is also known that variable Market Share (Structure) has a positive and
significant effect directly on Price Cost Margin. The Capital-Labour Ratio (Conduct) variable
directly to price cost margin (performance) has a positive but insignificant effect. The value of
the influence of market share variables on price-cost margin through the capital-labor ratio
variable is 0.097 or 9.7 percent. Variable Market Share (Structure) through Capital-Labour
Ratio (Conduct) indirectly to Price Cost Margin (Performance) positively but not significantly.
REFERENCES
Ambara, K. Y., Ustriyana, I. N. G., & Rantau, I. K. (2017). Profil usaha industri kecil tahu dan
tempe Makmur Jaya di Kecamatan Denpasar Barat, Kota Denpasar. E-Jurnal Agribisnis
Dan Agrowisata, 6(2).
Anindita, Ratya. (2004). Pemasaran hasil pertanian. Surabaya: Papyrus.
Bain, Joe S. (1959). Industrial organization. New York: Wiley.
BPS. (2020). Konsumsi dan pengeluaran (Consumption and expenditure). Jakarta: Badan
Pusat Statistik/Statistics of Indonesia.
Crossman, Ashley. (2020, January 15). Structural equation modeling.
Fidelis, Iweka, & Sunday, Onoshagbegbe Ejairu. (2018). Application and relevance of path
analysis in casual modeling. Global Journal of Arts, Humanities, and Social Sciences,
6(10), 26–50.
Analyzing the Structure-Conduct-Performance of the Tofu Industry in Banda Aceh
554 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(5), Feb 2022
Hall, Marshall, & Tideman, Nicola. (1967). Measures of concentration. Journal of the
American Statistical Association, 62(317), 162–168.
Koch, James v. (1980). Industrial organization and prices. New Jersey: Prentice-Hall.
Kotler, Philip. (2008). Marketing management (Manajemen marketing) (12th ed., Vol. 2).
Jakarta: Indeks.
Kvålseth, Tarald O. (2018). Relationship between concentration ratio and Herfindahl-
Hirschman index: A re-examination based on majorization theory. Heliyon, 4(10).
Lipczynski, John, Goddard, John, & Wilson, John O. S. (2017). Industrial organization:
Competition, strategy, and policy (5th ed.). London: Pearson.
Mankiw, N. Gregory. (2018). Principles of microeconomics. Boston: Cengage Learning.
Naylah, Maal. (2010). The influence of market structure on bank industry’s performance in
Indonesia (Pengaruh struktur pasar terhadap kinerja industri perbankan Indonesia).
Semarang.
Nguyễn, Cành & Nguyen, Liem & Thu, Phung & Nguyen Vinh, Khuong. (2019). The Impact
of Innovation on the Firm Performance and Corporate Social Responsibility of
Vietnamese Manufacturing Firms. Sustainability. 11. 3666.
Nzima, W., & Dzanja, J. (2015). Efficiency of soybean markets in Malawi: Structure, conduct
and performance approach. International Journal of Business and Social Science, 6(4).
OECD. (2003). OECD glossary of statistical terms: Concentration.
Raider, H.J. (1998). Market Structure and Innovation. Social Science Research, 27(1), 1-21
Rajapathirana, J., & Hui, Y. (2018). Relationship between innovation capability, innovation
type, and firm performance. Journal of Innovation & Knowledge, 3(1), 44-55
Rekarti, Endi, and Mafizatun Nurhayati. (2016). Analisis Structure Conduct Performance
(SCP) Jika Terjadi Merger Bank Pembangunan Daerah Dan Bank Bumn Persero
Berdasarkan Nilai Aset Dan Nilai Dana. Jurnal Ilmiah Manajemen dan Bisnis, 2(1).
Seperich, George J. (1994). Introduction to agribusiness marketing. New York: Pearson.
Shabastian, M. (2013). Pengaruh stategi harga dan strategi produk terhadap brand loyalty di
Tator Café Surabaya Town Square. Jurnal Strategi Pemasaran, 1(1).
Urata, S. (1979). Price-cost margins and foreign trade in U.S. textile and apparel industries: An
analysis of pooled cross-section and time-series data. Economics Letters, 4(3), 279-282
Zulfi, Said Kemal. (2015). Cartel on soy import through the law of business competition
(Kartel pada impor kedelai dalam perspektif hukum persaingan usaha). Yogyakarta.