Analysing the Settlement of Maritime Sovereignty’s Dispute Cases Based on UNCLOS 1982
599 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(5), Feb 2022
according to international law in the jurisdiction of each country that has ratified UNCLOS
1982. Disputes over these obscure territorial claims do not only happen once upon a time. Some
cases due to the vagueness of the sea boundary between the two countries include the dispute
over the islands of Sipadan and Ligitan won by Malaysia and the Malacca Strait issue that
occurred due to a misunderstanding of the two countries governing the Exclusive Economic
Zone.
The length of the exclusive economic zone boundary is 400 miles in and within this extent
the country is allowed to carry out activities. While in the case of the Strait of Malacca can be
observed and observed that the length of the Strait of Malacca from Indonesia to the coastal
region of Malaysia does not reach 400 miles23. This is what causes both countries to experience
the missed conception of each country's EEZ. In the end, the two countries agreed to a legal
settlement effort to set legal limits.
The overlap of EEZ of the two countries is due to the very close distance between the two
countries. Malaysia's EEZ entered the Indonesian EEZ and vice versa, this led to the need for
an international regime to facilitate dispute resolution. This dispute was then interspersed using
UNCLOS 1982 which Indonesia and Malaysia both ratified UNCLOS 1982. Thus, article 15
UNCLOS 1982 explains that the EEZ of overlapping countries is limited based on the middle
boundary of the two countries. This is an exception if the country has certain historical factors
that can strengthen the position to control the EEZ.
The background of the South China Sea dispute departs from the involvement of countries
including China, Taiwan, Vietnam, the Philippines, Malaysia, and Brunei Darussalam. This
conflict heated up again after the former had peaked during the Cold War. Basically, this
conflict began because of disputes over ownership of the Paracel and Spratly islands. The
islands were initially claimed by the People's Republic of China on historic grounds, but several
countries adjacent to the South China Sea protested. China feels it has long taken care of,
occupied, and utilized the results of the archipelago so insisted on gaining ownership of the
Paracel and Spratly islands. Sovereignty claims have historically been substantiated by China's
2000-year rule by the Chinese dynasty. On September 4, 1958, China issued a declaration that
the concerns of island groups in the territorial waters of the South China Sea belong to China
or the so-called Declaration of the Government of the People‟'s Republic of China on China's
Territorial Sea.
Not only that the island's territorial claims and waters were redeclared by China on
February 25, 1992, regarding territorial zones and additional zones. The declaration is called
The Law of the People's Republic of China on the Territorial Water and Contiguous Zone. But
instead of just China issuing claims, countries that are located nearby both issue claims.
The role of international law here is to provide options in dispute resolution. In unclos
regulation in article 33 of the UN Charter explained that dispute resolution efforts can be done
through various means. Some ways depend on the disputed country, can negotiate, inquiry,
conciliation, mediation, to arbitration.
A legal settlement based on UNCLOS' 1982 analysis of the South China Sea dispute can
be made by peaceful settlement between the two sides, as follows; (a) Judicial settlement, (b)
arbitration, (c) negotiation, conciliation, mediation, (d) settlement based on the system of the
United Nations (UN). Several ways can be done to resolve maritime disputes in the South