P-ISSN: 2808-0467
E-ISSN: 2808-5051
Homepage: https://iss.internationaljournallabs.com/index.php/iss
598 This work is licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0
ANALYSING THE SETTLEMENT OF MARITIME SOVEREIGNTY’S
DISPUTE CASES BASED ON UNCLOS 1982
Enno Haya Gladya Naranta
1
, Labib Muttaqin
2
Muhammadiyah University of Surakarta, Indonesia
1
ennogladya03@gmail.com
2
lm812@ums.ac.id
PAPER INFO ABSTRACT
Received:
February 2022
Revised:
February 2022
Approved:
February 2022
This paper was written to describe maritime sovereignty disputes under the
United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea 1982 (UNCLOS).
UNCLOS' 1982 role was enormous in resolving the South China Sea dispute,
Indonesia's Malaysian dispute, and the Natuna islands dispute. The
theoretical framework used in this paper to analyze case studies is the
international regime and the theory of compliance with maritime dispute
resolution. The results of this paper show that the jurisdiction of UNCLOS
1982 offers several paths in dispute resolution and prevents the occurrence
of perpetual sea disputes.
KEYWORDS
Maritime, UNCLOS 1982, South China Sea, Malacca strait, Natuna islands
INTRODUCTION
In the development of world history, maritime areas are the key for countries to be able to
rule the world. Some examples of countries that almost rule the world such as Spain, Portugal,
and the Netherlands have conducted expeditions in the sea region. In ancient times the sea was
the only effective means of relations with other countries. Countries that used to successfully
conduct expeditions around the world by sea lanes experience glory even today.
Sir Walter Raleigh, an English poet, said: "Whoever commands the sea, commands the
trade. Whoever commands the trade of the world, commands the riches of the world". It is true
that the sea is a strategic path in conducting political and economic relations for countries in
the world until now1. This quote seems to reinforce assumptions about the importance of
maritime to the country. In this case, it can be assumed that if a country can control the sea area
then the country can meet the needs of natural resources for its people. Therefore, the status of
state sovereignty over maritime areas is a great opportunity and advantage for countries that
want to develop strategic relations and even manage the natural potential in the maritime area.
Maritime areas are often problematic for countries due to uncertain sea boundaries. Such
problems usually cause disputes for the relevant countries. Disputes in the waters often occur
between countries that are located nearby. But it does not rule out the possibility if countries
that are geographically not close to the dispute. It cannot be denied that some disputes occur
because of illegal actions carried out in the territorial waters of a country. Territorial waters are
governed by the jurisdiction of the coastal state and adhere to the principle of extraterritorial2.
So that if a crime occurs in the territorial waters then the jurisdiction established can be
enforced in accordance with applicable law.
Maritime disputes can be resolved according to jurisdictions governed by the countries
involved. The United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) 1982 is considered
the highest law governing international sea law. UNCLOS 1982 is one of them regulates the
difference in the determination of territorial boundaries of coastal states and island countries.
A country's territorial sea is governed by a distance of 12 miles, the additional zone is 24 miles,
Analysing the Settlement of Maritime Sovereignty’s Dispute Cases Based on UNCLOS 1982
598 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(5), Feb 2022
and the exclusive economic zone (EEZ) is 200 miles measured from the baseline3. The
question of the status of territory and the vagueness of a country's maritime boundaries is often
a source of dispute between states. Disputes arise due to the application of different principles
to the establishment of continental shelf boundaries among neighboring countries, giving rise
to overlapping areas that can lead to maritime disputes.
The country's motives in disputes are often based on a desire to defend national sovereignty
and security. In this regard strategic control of the important position of sea transport routes,
fishing areas, exploration, and exploitation of crude oil and natural gas is also an important
aspect in maritime security. When discussing sovereignty often leads to sea disputes. This can
happen if the country feels its national stability is disrupted due to certain sea disputes.
It cannot be denied that if there is a dispute and impact on the national stability of a country
and national security then the affected country can dispute this. An example of the case in
Indonesia’s attitude that experienced instability in the economy due to the South China Sea
dispute. Indonesia's policy was issued to strengthen the EEZ in the Natuna islands adjacent to
the South China Sea which then resulted in an arbitration court ruling on June 12, 2016, has
expressly stated that the use of the terms nine-dash line, traditional fishing ground, and
historical right used by China is indeed unfounded and not in accordance with international sea
law.
It is recorded in history that some countries experienced maritime territorial disputes which
were then handled by the governing international regime. One of them is the case of maritime
disputes in Asia is taking place in the territorial waters of East and Southeast Asia. This is due
to disputes over the South China Sea, sea boundary disputes, and illegal fishing. It is true that
many maritime disputes involve countries with adjacent geographical locations. The existence
of differences in the perspective of formal marine regulations causes these disputes to often
occur.
METHOD
This research uses a type of qualitative research with a descriptive approach. The data used
in this study are primary data and secondary data. UNCLOS' 1982 role was enormous in
resolving the South China Sea dispute, Indonesia's Malaysian dispute, and the Natuna islands
dispute. The theoretical framework used in this paper to analyze case studies is the international
regime and the theory of compliance with maritime dispute resolution. The results of this paper
show that the jurisdiction of UNCLOS 1982 offers several paths in dispute resolution and
prevents the occurrence of perpetual sea disputes.
The qualitative research method is a research method based on the philosophy of
positivism, used to examine the natural object conditions, where the researcher is as a key
instrument, sampling data sources is done purposively and snowball, data collection techniques
with triangulation, data analysis is inductive/qualitative and research results emphasize
meaning more than generalization (Sugiyono, 2015: 19).
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The proximity of the outermost position between Indonesia and Malaysia causes problems
in setting each country's sea boundary. The sea boundary between Indonesia and Malaysia
overlaps due to the absence of clear jurisdiction. According to the concept of state territory
Analysing the Settlement of Maritime Sovereignty’s Dispute Cases Based on UNCLOS 1982
599 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(5), Feb 2022
according to international law in the jurisdiction of each country that has ratified UNCLOS
1982. Disputes over these obscure territorial claims do not only happen once upon a time. Some
cases due to the vagueness of the sea boundary between the two countries include the dispute
over the islands of Sipadan and Ligitan won by Malaysia and the Malacca Strait issue that
occurred due to a misunderstanding of the two countries governing the Exclusive Economic
Zone.
The length of the exclusive economic zone boundary is 400 miles in and within this extent
the country is allowed to carry out activities. While in the case of the Strait of Malacca can be
observed and observed that the length of the Strait of Malacca from Indonesia to the coastal
region of Malaysia does not reach 400 miles23. This is what causes both countries to experience
the missed conception of each country's EEZ. In the end, the two countries agreed to a legal
settlement effort to set legal limits.
The overlap of EEZ of the two countries is due to the very close distance between the two
countries. Malaysia's EEZ entered the Indonesian EEZ and vice versa, this led to the need for
an international regime to facilitate dispute resolution. This dispute was then interspersed using
UNCLOS 1982 which Indonesia and Malaysia both ratified UNCLOS 1982. Thus, article 15
UNCLOS 1982 explains that the EEZ of overlapping countries is limited based on the middle
boundary of the two countries. This is an exception if the country has certain historical factors
that can strengthen the position to control the EEZ.
The background of the South China Sea dispute departs from the involvement of countries
including China, Taiwan, Vietnam, the Philippines, Malaysia, and Brunei Darussalam. This
conflict heated up again after the former had peaked during the Cold War. Basically, this
conflict began because of disputes over ownership of the Paracel and Spratly islands. The
islands were initially claimed by the People's Republic of China on historic grounds, but several
countries adjacent to the South China Sea protested. China feels it has long taken care of,
occupied, and utilized the results of the archipelago so insisted on gaining ownership of the
Paracel and Spratly islands. Sovereignty claims have historically been substantiated by China's
2000-year rule by the Chinese dynasty. On September 4, 1958, China issued a declaration that
the concerns of island groups in the territorial waters of the South China Sea belong to China
or the so-called Declaration of the Government of the People‟'s Republic of China on China's
Territorial Sea.
Not only that the island's territorial claims and waters were redeclared by China on
February 25, 1992, regarding territorial zones and additional zones. The declaration is called
The Law of the People's Republic of China on the Territorial Water and Contiguous Zone. But
instead of just China issuing claims, countries that are located nearby both issue claims.
The role of international law here is to provide options in dispute resolution. In unclos
regulation in article 33 of the UN Charter explained that dispute resolution efforts can be done
through various means. Some ways depend on the disputed country, can negotiate, inquiry,
conciliation, mediation, to arbitration.
A legal settlement based on UNCLOS' 1982 analysis of the South China Sea dispute can
be made by peaceful settlement between the two sides, as follows; (a) Judicial settlement, (b)
arbitration, (c) negotiation, conciliation, mediation, (d) settlement based on the system of the
United Nations (UN). Several ways can be done to resolve maritime disputes in the South
Analysing the Settlement of Maritime Sovereignty’s Dispute Cases Based on UNCLOS 1982
600 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(5), Feb 2022
China Sea. Dispute resolution under UNCLOS 1982 and DOC 2002, among others, is as
follows;
a. Mediation and Negotiation
The countries involved in the dispute are the Philippines, Malaysia, Vietnam and Brunei
Darussalam. These countries then agreed to hold a meeting with China as the country that
controls a cluster of islands in the South China Sea. Another way is to use a third party or
commonly called mediation. Mediators here serve to assist in the resolution of disputes
between several Southeast Asian countries along with China.
b. Settlement through International Organizations
The South China Sea dispute can be resolved through southeast Asia's international
organization ASEAN. This is because most of the disputed countries are ASEAN member
states even though China as a defendant country is not a member of ASEAN. But
jurisdictionally UNCLOS 1982 this can be done.
c. Settlement through Arbitration
Until now, the resolution of this dispute is still done through arbitration proceedings. The
Philippines as the plaintiff country filed a lawsuit at the international arbitration court, of which
China is the defendant. The main lawsuit is on the issue of reclamation carried out by China
on a cluster of islands in the South China Sea.
d. Settlement Through Conciliation
Conciliation can also be carried out by disputed countries in the south China Sea case.
e. Settlement through the International Court of Justice
Disputes can also be resolved through the International Court of Justice (ICJ), an
international court of justice. The ICJ is also the main judicial body of the United Nations.
f. Settlement through the International Court of The Law of the Sea
This court is different from UNCLOS, but the International Tribunal for the Law of the
Sea (ITLOS) is a special judicial body. Disputes over the South China Sea can be resolved
through this particular judicial body. Procedures in ITLOS are based on UNCLOS 1982.
ITLOS conducts dispute resolution on the basis of the error of countries in interpreting
UNCLOS 1982.
CONCLUSION
Maritime disputes are a problem that often occurs in countries that have sea areas. Some
countries dispute to get property rights to territorial waters, islands, to access to manage natural
resources. The question of the vagueness of a boundary causes different interpretations of each
country in understanding the boundaries of a region's continental shelf. Disputes over territorial
claims occur due to the vagueness of these boundaries. The author uses the frame of mind of
the internationally institutionalized regime that is the United Nations Convention on the Law
of the Sea 1982 (UNCLOS). Thus the settlement in dispute claims of this maritime territory
author refers to the legal jurisdiction of UNCLOS 1982 and settlement under UNCLOS 1982.
It cannot be denied that this maritime sovereignty dispute is based on the desire to obtain
official status under the law to manage all natural potentials in a region. In the South China Sea
dispute, the role of international law is large but still experiencing obstacles and is still in the
process of resolving disputes, while in the case of the Malacca strait and illegal fishing in the
Natuna islands the role of international law here is effective until the dispute resolution period.
Analysing the Settlement of Maritime Sovereignty’s Dispute Cases Based on UNCLOS 1982
601 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(5), Feb 2022
It can be concluded that the role of international law is very important both based on the
adoption of formal legal regulations into the official rule of law of the state and the resolution
of disputes that follow the flow of international law. A legal settlement shall make the outcomes
set forth in this dispute an official decree. UNCLOS 1982 is considered potent in resolving
disputes over maritime sovereignty based on case studies in this article.
REFERENCES
1. Dhiana Puspitawati. Hukum Laut Internasional. Depok: Kencana; 2017.
2. Mochtar Kusumaatmadja. Hukum Laut Internasional. Bandung: Penerbit Binacipta; 1986.
3. Siahaan dan Suhendi. Hukum Laut Nasional (Himpunan Peraturan Perundang
Undangan Kemaritiman). Jakarta: Penerbit Djambatan; 1989.
4. Aaron L. Connelly. Indonesia di Laut Cina Selatan : Berjalan Sendiri. Lowy Inst Int
Policy. 2017.
5. Lasabuda R. Pembangunan Wilayah Pesisir dan Lautan. J Ilm Platax Vol 1. 2013.
6. Natalya K. Penyelesaian Permasalahan Batas Wilayah Antara Indonesia dan Malaysia
ditinjau dari UNCLOS 1982. J Ilm Mhs Univ Surabaya. 2013;2.
7. Gilbert P. The Philosophy of Nationalism. (1, ed.). New York: Routledge; 2018.
8. Satnyoto A. Perspektif Teori Institusionalisme dan Teori Kritis terhadap Rezim
Internasional. Interdependence. 2007;5:9.
9. Krasner SD. International Regimes. New York; 1983.
10. Etzoni A. A Comprehensive Analysis of Complex Organizations. New York; 1975.
11. Samuel Barkin. International Organization: Theories and Institutions. New York; 2006.
12. Michael Sheng-ti Gau. The Interpretation of Article 121(3) of UNCLOS by the Tribunal
for the South China Sea Arbitration: A Critique. Ocean Dev Int Law. 2019;50:49-51.
13. Tirtamulia T. Zona-Zona Laut UNCLOS 1982. Surabaya: Brilian Internasional; 2011.
14. Stephen C. Nemeth, Sara McLaughlin Mitchell EAN& PR, Hensel. Ruling the Sea:
Managing Maritime Conflicts through UNCLOS and Exclusive Economic Zones. Int
Interact Empir Theor Res Int Relations. 2014.
15. Djajal H. Indonesia and the South China Sea Initiative. Ocean Dev Int Law. 2001;32:97-
103.
16. TIARA AJI DAMASTUTI1, RIVINTA CAHYU HENDRIANTI2, RORO OKTAVIA
LARAS RA. PENYELESAIAN SENGKETA ILEGAL FISHING DI WILAYAH LAUT
NATUNA ANTARA INDONESIA DENGAN CHINA. J Reformasi Huk Cogito Ergo
Sum. 2018;1.
17. UN. United Nations Convention on The Law of The Sea (UNCLOS) 1982.; 1982.
18. Agastia D. Years Later, Where Is Indonesia’s “Global Maritime Fulcrum”?
https://thediplomat.com/2017/11/3-years-later-where-is-indonesias-global- maritime-
fulcrum/. Published 2017. Accessed November 22, 2017.
19. ASEAN. Declaration on The Conduct of Parties in The South China Sea. ASEAN.
http://asean.org/?static_post=declaration-on-the-conduct-of-parties- in-the-south-china-
sea-2. Published 2012.
20. Bateman S. UNCLOS and Its Limitations as the Foundation for a Regional Maritime
Security Regime. Korean J Def Anal. 2006;19:29-34.
Analysing the Settlement of Maritime Sovereignty’s Dispute Cases Based on UNCLOS 1982
602 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(5), Feb 2022
21. Odeyemi C. UNCLOS and maritime security: the “securitisation” of the South China Sea
disputes. Def Secur Anal. 2015;31.
22. Maximo Paulino T. Sison III. Universalizing the Law of the Sea in the South China Sea
Dispute. Ocean Dev Int Law. 2018;49:159-160.
23. Ben Dolven, Jennifer K. Elsea, Susan V. Lawrence, Ronald O’Rourke and IER. Chinese
Land Reclamation in the South China Sea: Implications and Policy Options,
Congressional Research Service (CRS) Report.; 2015.
24. Evelyn Goh. Meeting the China Challenge: The U.S. in Southeast Asian Regional Security
Strategies. East-West Cent Washingt. 2005.
25. Purwaka TH. Tinjauan Hukum Laut terhadap Wilayah Negara Kesatuan Republik
Indonesia. Mimb Huk. 2014;26(3):345-349.
26. UN. United Nation Convention on the Law of The Sea 1982. Statuta Roma; 1982.
27. Schofield C. A Geopolitical Overview of the South China Sea.; 2009.
28. Dahuri R. pembangunan Kelautan dan Perikanan Menuju Indonesia yang Maju,Adil
Makmur, dan Berdaulat. PKSPL-IPB. 2010:15.
29. Riska E. Diplomasi Maritim Indonesia terhadap Aktivitas Penangkapan Ikan Ilegal (Ilegal
Fishing) oleh Nelayan China di ZEEI Perairan Kepulauan Natuna, Pertahanan. J Prodi
Diplomasi. 2007;3(2):48-51.
30. Wang JS. Safety Assessment of Shipping Routes in the South China Sea Based on the
Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process. 62 Saf Sci. 2014;46.
31. Zuleta B. Introduction,” in The Law of the Sea. United Nations Convention on the Law of
the Sea with Index and Final Act of the Third United Nations Conference on the Law of
the Sea. St Martin’s Press. 1983;5:71-78