P-ISSN: 2808-0467
E-ISSN: 2808-5051
Homepage: https://iss.internationaljournallabs.com/index.php/iss
1000 This work is licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0
AUDITS QUALITY IN MEDIATING PROFITABILITY, LIQUIDITY,
AUDIT LAG, PRIOR OPINION ON ACCEPTING GOING CONCERN
AUDITS
Anugrana Mulyawati
*
, Agus Munandar
Faculty of Economics and Business, Esa Unggul University, Jakarta, DKI Jakarta, Indonesia
*
anugrana3@gmail.com
PAPER INFO ABSTRACT
Received: April
2022
Revised: May
2022
Approved: May
2022
Background: Researchers believe that research on audit opinion going
concern will continue to be interesting as a research material on an ongoing
basis, this is because the going concern audit opinion can be an important
signal for companies in determining management policies and also become a
consideration for investors in investing their money.
Aim: This research aims to analyze the role of audit quality in mediating the
influence of profitability, liquidity, audit lag, and prior opinion on the
acceptance of audit opinion going concerned.
Method: Purposive sampling technique is used for sample processing, and
companies that fit the sampling criteria are as many as 17 companies in the
year of the research period (2015-2019), then the total observations processed
are 85 samples. The research methodology uses the SPSS program with
hypothesis testing using logistic regression analysis.
Findings: From the results of the test, the prior opinion variable can partially
affect the quality audit, and the variables of profitability, liquidity, and audit
lag do not affect the quality of the audit. Then, the results of partial tests of
audit opinions going concerned with profitability and prior opinion are
influential, but liquidity and audit lag does not have an effect. The results of
audit quality variable tests on audit opinions have a significant influence. The
results of the track analysis prove that audit quality variables cannot mediate
variables of profitability, liquidity, audit lag, and prior opinion to audit
opinion going concerned.
KEYWORDS
going concern opinion, profitability, liquidity, audit lag, prior opinion
INTRODUCTION
The purpose of an entity in running its business is one of them is so that the survival (going
concern) of its business can last for a long time. Nugroho et al (2018) stated that for companies
listed in the capital market, the provision of audit opinions going concern is important for the
company's management, even though this is because the company's survival (going concern)
will be reflected in the company's reputation and performance. The survival (going concern)
of the company is doubtful if, for the next year, the survival of the company is considered
untenable. The concept of assessment of going concern can be used as an initial warning for
all stakeholders so that the company can maintain its survival.
The current phenomenon, based on the 2019 annual report, the growth of GDP (Gross
Domestic Products) of the textile and apparel industry from 2015 - 2019 has seen a significant
increase, especially in 2019. The textile and apparel industry is growing and able to grow to
8.73% in 2018 which was previously only -4.79% in 2015, and grew by 20.71% in TW II 2019.
But with the growth of the textile industry that is getting better every year, it does not make
textile and apparel companies (garments) have good certainty of their business continuity. This
Audits Quality in Mediating Profitability, Liquidity, Audit Lag, Prior Opinion on Accepting Going Concern
Audits
1001 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(8), May 2022
is evident from the existence of several textile and apparel companies (Garments) to get
opinions going concern from auditors on the continuity of their business. Several textile and
apparel (garment) companies obtained consecutive going concern audit opinions, namely, PT
Argo Pantes Tbk (ARGO) in 2015-2019, the cause of which was that the company experienced
capital deficiency and also experienced business losses. The same thing happened to PT Asia
Pacific Investama Tbk (MYTX) which also successively received audit opinions going concern
because of a deficit caused by its operating expenses on the company. The ineffectiveness of
the steps taken by management to improve the unstable condition of the company is also a
factor in the company always obtaining consecutive audit going concern opinions. The event
explained that the audit opinion going concern became an important thing for the company.
Something that the company does not want the most is to obtain an audit opinion going
concern, this is because it causes a decline in the stock price, a loss of investor and creditor
confidence, consumers and employees to the company's management, and also the difficulty
of the company to increase loan capital (Krissindiastuti & Rasmini, 2016). Financial and non-
financial factors can both influence the provision of audit opinions going concern. Things that
can make the auditor issue an audit opinion going concern are important to know as an early
warning for the company for its business continuity and also a consideration for investors in
investing their money.
The performance of a company can be assessed by looking at its ability to generate profits.
According to Kasmir (2015), the profitability ratio is a calculation used to see the performance
of a company to get a profit. If the profitability ratio is higher, it is assumed that the better the
company's performance, the that the tendency to obtain audit opinions will also be lower.
The liquidity of an ordinary company is calculated using a current ratio by dividing the
number of current assets by the number of current liabilities. Kurbani et al.’s research (2019)
explained that the lower the liquidity of a company, the more likely the auditor is to provide an
audit opinion going concern, because it is believed that the company cannot be timely in
meeting its short-term debt.
Audit lag can be interpreted as the number of calendar dates between the date of the annual
financial statements and the end of the auditor in his work in the field. In research conducted
by Anita (2017), Audit Lag has a positive influence on the acceptance of audit opinion going
concern. If in the implementation of the audit there is a long audit lag, it will cause the tendency
of the auditor to elaborate the audit opinion going concern towards the company.
Prior opinions received by the company can be used as consideration for auditors to issue
audit going concern opinions in the current year if in the previous year the company also
obtained an audit opinion going concern. This can happen when the company's financial
situation is significantly unchanged.
Audit quality is usually interpreted as an image or good name obtained from the auditee's
trust in his responsibility as a qualified auditor and also good performance (Aria & Pasaribu, 2015).
In this case, the Public Accounting Firm that cooperates with kap big four is assumed to be
more competent in audit quality than non-big four KAP.
In some previous research, there are many factors that can influence auditors to provide
audit opinions going concerns that vary greatly and have varying results as well. Kurbani et al.
(2019) the results of their research state that liquidity and profitability have a significant effect
on the opinion of audit going concern and audit quality is a variable that mediates liquidity and
Audits Quality in Mediating Profitability, Liquidity, Audit Lag, Prior Opinion on Accepting Going Concern
Audits
1002 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(8), May 2022
profitability variables against audit opinion going concern. However, in the research of
Nugroho et al. (2018) the results of his research stated that profitability and liquidity do not
have a significant influence on audit opinion going concern. Likewise, Anita's research (2017)
lag audit results have a positive influence on audit opinion going concern, while research from
Safitri (2017), the quality of audits and lag audits have no impact on audit opinion going
concern.
Researchers believe that research on audit opinion going concern will continue to be
interesting as research material on an ongoing basis, this is because the going concern audit
opinion can be an important signal for companies in determining management policies and also
become a consideration for investors in investing their money. In this study, the financial
factors used by the authors are profitability and liquidity, while audit lag, prior opinion and
audit quality as non-financial factors. It is hoped that the results of research on audit opinion
going concern can provide benefits as a basis for making a decision to assess the survival of an
entity or company, and can also provide the development of accounting literature.
This research aims to analyze the role of audit quality in mediating the influence of
profitability, liquidity, audit lag, and prior opinion on the receipt of opinions audit going
concern. The novelty in this research is a different year period, namely 2015-2019. This
research also included variable intervening audit quality to mediate between independent
variables to dependent variables. In this research, intervening variable testing uses path analysis
methods. The object of research focuses only on textile and garment sector companies.
Research Model
Source: The Researchers’ Formulation
Figure 1. Research Model
METHOD
This research approach uses quantitative research which is a causal design, a type of
research that explains the causal relationship between two or more variables. The method of
collecting data in this research is in the form of documentation by collecting secondary data.
This research uses financial statements and annual reports (Annual Reports) of textile and
typer sector companies listed on the Indonesia Stock Exchange from 2015 to 2019. Purposive
Audits Quality in Mediating Profitability, Liquidity, Audit Lag, Prior Opinion on Accepting Going Concern
Audits
1003 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(8), May 2022
sampling techniques are used for sample processing and companies that fit the sampling
criteria, namely as many as 17 companies in the year of the study period (2015-2019), then the
total observations processed are 85 samples.
In this research, the data analysis methods used are descriptive statistical analysis, data
quality tests, hypothesis tests, and intervening tests. Path analysis techniques are used for
intervening tests.
In the regression process, there are audit quality variables that become dependent variables
as well as independent variables for testing audit opinions going concern. This research
regression equation is:
1) Testing variable profitability, liquidity, audit lag, and prior opinion of audit quality,
regression equations for this test are:
2) The second test is carried out to see the impact of the quality of the audit on the
acceptance of audit opinion going concerns. The regression equations of this test are:
3) The third test is carried out to test the variables of profitability, liquidity, audit lag, and
prior opinion on the receipt of audit opinion going concern. The test regression equation
is as follows:
Information:
Profit = Profitability Liquid = Liquidity AL = Audit Lag
PO = Prior Opinion KA = Audit Quality
OAGC = Audit Opinion Going Concern α = Constant
𝛽
1
- 𝛽
9
= Regression coefficient 𝑒
1
- 𝑒
3
= Residual error
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Descriptive Statistical Results
Descriptive statistical analysis is performed to determine the maximum, mean, minimum,
and standard deviation values of each variable. Descriptive statistic results are presented as
follows.
Table 1. Descriptive Statistics
Variable
N
Minimum
Maximum
Std. Deviation
Profitability
85
-39,18
9,94
7,75588
Liquidity
85
0,09
6,51
1,61004
Ln ( KA ) = α + 𝛽
1
(Profit) + 𝛽
2
(Liquid) + 𝛽
3
(AL) + 𝛽
4
(PO)+𝑒
1
1-KA
Ln ( OAGC ) = α + 𝛽
5
(KA) + 𝑒
2
1 - OAGC
Ln ( OAGC ) = α + 𝛽
6
(Profit) + 𝛽
7
(Liquid) + 𝛽
8
(AL) + 𝛽
9
(PO) + 𝑒
3
1 – OAGC
Audits Quality in Mediating Profitability, Liquidity, Audit Lag, Prior Opinion on Accepting Going Concern
Audits
1004 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(8), May 2022
Audit Lag
85
66
191
22,703
PO
85
0
1
0,427
OAGC
85
0
1
0,427
KA
85
0
1
0,453
Sumber: Data Processed in 2021
The results of the descriptive statistics, namely, for the profitability variable in the study
obtained a mean value of -2.20 and a standard deviation of 7.75. The data showed that in the
research period, most textile and garment sector manufacturing companies became business
sectors that did not promise profits, this was because the majority of textile and garment
companies suffered losses.
The lowest profitability value was experienced by PT Panasia Indo Resources Tbk with a
loss of 39.18% in the 2018 financial year. While the company that achieved the highest
profitability was PT Eratex Djaja Tbk which was able to record a profit of 9.94% in 2015. For
liquidity variables, a mean value of 1.71 and a standard deviation of 1.61 is obtained, while for
the minimum value of the liquidity variable of 0.09 reported by PT Panasia Indo Resources
Tbk in 2019, for the maximum value of the liquidity variable of 6.51 reported by PT Pan
Brothers Tbk. This indicates if the majority of the company is in a safe condition in paying off
its short-term obligations.
Then for the audit variable lag, the mean value is 92.84, the standard deviation is 22.70,
66 days for the minimum value while 191 days is the maximum value. This result illustrates
that the majority of companies have a fairly long audit lag in the audit process with an average
value of more than 90 days.
The prior opinion variable gets a mean value f 0.24 and a standard deviation of 0.42. The
audit quality variable gets a mean value of 0.28 and 0.45 for the standard deviation result. This
can be interpreted if in the observation period the majority of textile and garment companies
use audit services from KAP non-Big Four because in that period textile and garment
companies tend to experience losses, so companies will do more effective and efficient of
expenditure not least in the budget of audit services used.
For the opinion variable audit going concern obtains a mean value of 0.24 and a standard
deviation value of 0.42. This means that only a small percentage of textile and garment
companies receive audit opinions and the majority of companies are still considered eligible to
continue their operations in the future even though many companies experience financial
problems that tend to suffer losses, this is evident from the audit opinion going concern. Given
by auditors only to a small percentage of companies that are considered unable to overcome
their financial problems.
Overall Model Testing
The overall test of the model is used to see whether or not the model is hypothesized with
the data. The trick is to compare the values between -2 Log-Likelihood (-2LogL) beginning
and end, if there is a decrease then this indicates a better regression model (Ghozali, 2018).
Here are the results of the overall test of the fit model:
Audits Quality in Mediating Profitability, Liquidity, Audit Lag, Prior Opinion on Accepting Going Concern
Audits
1005 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(8), May 2022
Table 2. Model Overall Test (Overall Model Fit)
Iterations
-2 Log
likelihood
Coefficients
Constant
Profitability
Liquidity
Audit Lag
PO
KA
Step
1
1
38,319
-2,813
-0,068
-0,043
0,014
2,046
-0,349
2
24,700
-4,811
-0,149
-0,075
0,028
2,610
-0,715
3
19,741
-7,130
-0,222
-0,119
0,047
3,141
-1,187
4
17,933
-9,735
-0,278
-0,202
0,072
3,635
-1,814
5
17,458
-11,803
-0,321
-0,269
0,091
4,053
-2,347
6
17,411
-12,676
-0,341
-0,293
0,099
4,254
-2,555
7
17,410
-12,795
-0,343
-0,295
0,100
4,284
-2,578
8
17,410
-12,797
-0,344
-0,295
0,100
4,285
-2,578
9
17,410
-12,797
-0,344
-0,295
0,100
4,285
-2,578
Initial -2 Log Likelihood: 92,751
Source: Data Processed in 2021
Based on table 2 shows the value of -2 Log-Likelihood (-2LogL) dropped to 17,410 from
the initial value of 92,751 after the inclusion of four independent variables and intervening
variables, this indicates a better regression model and the assumed model also matches the data.
Regression Model Feasibility Testing
The chi-square values on Hosmer and Lemeshow's tables are used to assess the feasibility
of regression models. This test is to see the null hypothesis, and whether the empirical data is
consistent with the regression model in the study (the model is no different from the data, hence
the fit model) (Ghozali, 2018). Test results are presented in the following table:
Table 3. Regression Model Feasibility Test
Step
Chi-square
df
Sig.
1
0,286
7
1,000
Source: Data Processed in 2021
The data resulted in a Chi-Square value of 0.286 and a significance value of 1,000. The
significance value obtained was > 0.05 (>5%), which means that H0
cannot be rejected. This
indicates if the regression model is suitable to be used as a model to predict observations in
research.
Determination Coefficient Testing (Nagelkerke R Square)
Here is a table to see how much the determination coefficient value of the logistic
regression model is:
Audits Quality in Mediating Profitability, Liquidity, Audit Lag, Prior Opinion on Accepting Going Concern
Audits
1006 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(8), May 2022
Table 4. Determination Coefficient Test
Step
-2 Logg likelihood
Cox & Snell R Square
Nagelkerke R Square
10
17,410
a
0,588
0,885
Source: Data Processed in 2021
The Nagelkerker R Square value obtained in this study was 0.885 which means 88.5% of
the variability of bound variables is described by the free variable and the remaining 11.5% is
explained by other variables not included in the research model.
Multicollinearity Testing
Multicollinearity testing aims to test correlations between free variables on regression
models (Ghozali, 2018). Regression models are considered good if there is no evidence of a
strong correlation between independent variables. Multicollinearity testing uses a correlation
matrix between independent variables. The following table is the results of the multicoloniality
test:
Table 5. Multicollinearity Correlation Matrix Test
Constant
Profitability
Liquidity
Audit Lag
PO
KA
Step
1
Constant
1,000
,483
,178
-,955
-,663
,271
Profitability
,483
1,000
-,245
-,344
-,252
,632
Liquidity
,178
-,245
1,000
-,375
-,107
-,193
Audit Lag
-,955
-,344
-,375
1,000
,532
-,280
PO
-,663
-,252
-,107
,532
1,000
,123
KA
,271
,632
-,193
-,280
,123
1,000
Source: Data Processed in 2021
Prediction Accuracy Testing
Classification matrices are used to predict the probability of a company getting an audit
opinion going concern, as well as to show the strength of a regression model. Here is a table of
prediction accuracy tests:
Table 6. Classification Matrix
Classification Table
a,b
Observed
Predicted
OAGC
Percentage
Correct
Non-GC
GC
Step 0
OAGC
Non-Going
Concern
65
0
100,0
Going Concern
20
0
,0
Overall Percentage
76,5
Source: Data Processed in 2021
Audits Quality in Mediating Profitability, Liquidity, Audit Lag, Prior Opinion on Accepting Going Concern
Audits
1007 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(8), May 2022
Judging from the table, the overall predictive strength of the regression model is 76.5%.
This means that the logistics model in this study has a high enough accuracy value to predict
audit opinions going concerns in textile companies and garments listed on the Indonesia Stock
Exchange.
Logistic Regression Coefficient Testing
In this research, the hypothesis test is divided into several phases of testing. The first phase
in tables 7 and 8 test the variables of profitability, liquidity, audit lag, and prior opinion on
audit quality, the second phase in table 9 assesses the impact of audit quality on the receipt of
audit opinions going concern, then the third phase is trudgable 10 and 11 to test dependent
variables against independent variables partially and simultaneously. Here is a table of SPSS
data processing results:
Table 7. Variable Partial Audit Quality Logistics Regression Coefficient Test in the
Equation
B
S.E.
Wald
Df
Sig.
Exp(B)
Step 1
a
Profitability
-,043
,045
,945
1
,331
,958
Liquidity
,001
,166
,000
1
,995
1,001
Audit Lag
,004
,017
,053
1
,817
1,004
PO
-2,948
1,312
5,047
1
,025
,052
Constant
-,946
1,444
,429
1
,513
,388
Source: Data Processed in 2021
The models resulting from the results of the logistic regression coefficient test are:
Ln (KA) = -0.945 – 0.043 (Profit) + 0.001 (Liquid) + 0.004 (AL) – 2,948 (PO) + e
1 – KA
Table 8. Simultaneous Audit Quality Logistic Regression Coefficient Test
Omnibus Tests of Model Coefficients
Chi-square
df
Sig.
Step 1
Step
9,839
.4
,043
Block
9,839
.4
,043
Model
9,839
.4
,043
Source: Data Processed in 2021
Based on table 8, the sig value on the model is 0.043. The sig value < 5% (0.05) then the
results of the simultaneous test (omnibus test) explain if the variables of profitability, liquidity,
audit lag, and prior opinion are appropriate regression models where simultaneously the results
of all these independent variables can affect the audit quality variables. Then with this H5 is
accepted.
Audits Quality in Mediating Profitability, Liquidity, Audit Lag, Prior Opinion on Accepting Going Concern
Audits
1008 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(8), May 2022
Table 9. Going Concern Opinion Logistic Regression Coefficient Test
Variables in the Equation
B
S.E.
Wald
df
Sig.
Exp(B)
Step
1
a
KA
-2,342
1,058
4,899
1
,027
,096
Constant
-,793
,276
8,231
1
,004
,452
Source: Data Processed in 2021
The models resulting from the results of the logistic regression coefficient test are:
Ln (OAGC) = -0.793 – 2,342 (KA) + e
1 – OAGC
Table 10. Partial Going Concern Opinion Logistic Regression Coefficient Test
Variables in the Equation
B
S.E.
Wald
df
Sig.
Exp(B)
Step 1
a
Profitability
-,275
,103
7,216
1
,007
,759
Liquidity
-,459
,679
,457
1
,499
,632
Audit Lag
,086
,047
3,400
1
,065
1,090
PO
4,853
1,636
8,797
1
,003
128,146
Constant
-11,825
4,916
5,787
1
,016
,000
Source: Data Processed in 2021
The results of the logistic regression coefficient test produce the following models:
Ln (OAGC) = -11,825 – 0.275 (Profit) – 0.459 (Liquid) + 0.086 (AL) + 4,853 (PO) + e
1 – OAGC
Table 11. Logistic Regression Coefficient Test Opinion Going Concern Simultaneously
Omnibus Tests of Model Coefficients
Chi-square
df
Sig.
Step 1
Step
73,468
4
,000
Block
73,468
4
,000
Model
73,468
4
,000
Source: Data Processed in 2021
In table 11 sig numbers on the model are 0.000. The sig value < 5% (0.000 < 0.05) then
the results of the simultaneous test (omnibus test) show that the variables of profitability,
liquidity, audit lag, and prior opinion are good regression models where simultaneously all
independent variables affect the variables of audit opinion concern going. . This means that
H10
is accepted.
Hypothesis Testing
From the first research model test, it can be known that profitability gets a significance
value of 0.331 which means that profitability does not have a significant influence on audit
Audits Quality in Mediating Profitability, Liquidity, Audit Lag, Prior Opinion on Accepting Going Concern
Audits
1009 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(8), May 2022
quality. H1 was rejected. This finding is not in line with Subekti (2005) in Hasty, et al (2017)
who obtained profitability results positively impacting audit quality. This breaks the
assumption that only companies with high profitability can use the services of BIG FOUR KAP
auditors. However, many of the losers still use the services of KAP Big Four auditors for their
companies.
Based on the first research model test, liquidity has a significant value of 0.995 with a β of
1,001, which indicates liquidity has no impact on audit quality. With this H
2
is rejected.
Liquidity cannot affect the quality of audits because companies with low liquidity levels will
still use audit services with good audit quality.
From the test results above, audit lag has a significant characteristic of 0.817 which means
that audit lag has no effect on the quality of the audit. Based on this, H3 is rejected. This result
is in line with Herianti & Suryani's research (2016). The time needed in completing an audit
on a company cannot be a benchmark of audit quality.
In the test results, prior opinion gets a significance value of < 0.05 with a β -2,948, which
means that prior opinion has an influence on the quality of the audit. Then with this H4 is
accepted. Prior opinion can be a consideration for auditors in expressing their opinions.
The results of the profitability model test measured using ROA obtained a significance
value of 0.007 means that < 0.05 which indicates if profitability has an influence on the
acceptance of audit opinion going concern. This means that H6 is
accepted. The same results
as Kurbani et al. (2019). With higher profitability, the company's performance is considered
better, so the tendency to obtain audit opinions will be lower.
In the test results of the liquidity measurement model using the current ratio, the
significance value obtained >0.05 so that liquidity has no influence on the acceptance of audit
opinion going concern. H7 was rejected. This shows that the smaller the current ratio, the lower
the company's ability to meet its short-term obligations. However, the auditor considers not
only the entity's ability to fulfill its short-term obligations in providing a going concern opinion
but also the entity's ability to fulfill all of its obligations. This finding is in accordance with
Anita's research (2017), the high level of liquidity of a company cannot be used as a benchmark
to obtain opinions going concern.
Based on the results of the model test, the lag audit obtained a significance value of 0.065
with a β of 0.086, meaning that the lag audit had no effect on the receipt of the audit going
concern opinion. This means that
H8
is rejected. The length of time it takes for the auditor to
conduct an audit cannot be used as a benchmark in the acceptance of audit opinion going
concern. A long audit lag is not a guarantee that the entity will obtain an audit opinion going
concern, nor is it an indication of a going concern problem for the audited entity. These results
are in accordance with Safitri's research (2017).
In the test results, prior opinion has a significance value of < 0.05 and β 4,853 which means
that prior opinion affects the acceptance of audit opinion going concern. H9 is accepted. Similar
results from Risamasu & Christiawan (2017). The prior opinion is important for auditors in
considering to provide audit opinions going concern, this is because if in the previous year the
auditee received an audit opinion going concern and in the current year there are no effective
measures to improve the situation, the possibility to receive an audit opinion going concern
again will be higher.
Audits Quality in Mediating Profitability, Liquidity, Audit Lag, Prior Opinion on Accepting Going Concern
Audits
1010 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(8), May 2022
Based on the results of the model test, the audit quality obtained a significance value of
0.027 and β -2,342, this means that the quality of the audit can have an impact on the acceptance
of audit opinion going concern. H11 is accepted. Large or good quality auditors tend to be very
careful in parsing audit opinions going concerns. Similar results in Krissindiastuti & Rasmini
research (2016).
Path Analysis Testing
Path analysis is also called the use of regression analysis to estimate the quality of
relationships between predetermined variables based on theory (Ghozali, 2018). This path
analysis technique is used to determine the direct or indirect influence of related variables.
Calculating from the results of path analysis, the result is:
Source: Data Processed in 2021
Figure 2. Path Analysis
Table 12. Path Analysis Calculation
Variable
Indirect Influence
Direct Influence
Profitability
0,958 x 0,096 = 0,092
0,759
Liquidity
1,001 x 0,096 = 0,096
0,632
Audit Lag
1,004 x 0,096 = 0,096
1,09
Prior Opinion
0,052 x 0,096 = 0,005
128,146
Source: Data Processed in 2021
Based on the table shows that the audit quality is not able to mediate the four independent
variables, namely profitability, liquidity, audit lag, and prior opinion of dependent variables.
This can be seen from the coefficient value (β) of indirect influence of all independent variables
smaller than the coefficient (β) of direct influence.
From the presentation of the details of the analysis of the above path can be concluded the
value between indirect influence (PTL) and direct influence (PL) is:
PTL = (to x i) + (b x i) + (c x i) + (d x i)
= (0,958 x 0,096 ) + (1,001 x 0,096) + (1,004 x 0,096) + (0,052 x 0,096)
Audits Quality in Mediating Profitability, Liquidity, Audit Lag, Prior Opinion on Accepting Going Concern
Audits
1011 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(8), May 2022
= 0,289
PL = (e + f + g + h)
= (0,759 + 0,632 + 1,090 + 128,146)
= 130,627
Based on the results of the calculation above, it can be seen that the beta value (β) of the
Indirect Influence (PTL) is smaller than the beta value (β) of Direct Influence (PL) (PTL <
PL), it can be concluded if the audit quality variables in this study cannot mediate between
independent variables, namely profitability, liquidity, audit. lag, and prior opinion with
dependent variables, namely the acceptance of audit opinions going concern.
Table 13. Sobel Test Calculation
Variable
Sig.
Information
X1 -> Z -> Y
0,92770203
Not Sig (sobel test)
X2 -> Z -> Y
0,92770954
Not Sig (sobel test)
X3 -> Z -> Y
0,92770139
Not Sig (sobel test)
X4 -> Z -> Y
0,97102686
Not Sig (sobel test)
Source: Data Processed in 2021
Based on the results of the Sobel test calculation in the table above shows that each
independent variable has an insignificant value. This explains that the quality of the audit
cannot be a mediation variable between variables independent of their dependent variables
partially.
CONCLUSION
The results of the logistic regression test show that partially the prior opinion variable can
affect the quality of the audit, while the variables of profitability, liquidity, and audit lag cannot
affect the quality of the audit. For variable testing of profitability, liquidity, audit lag and prior
opinion of audit quality simultaneously have an influence. Partial test results show that
profitability and prior opinion variables have an influence on the acceptance of audit opinions
going concern, but liquidity variables and audit lag have no effect on audit going concern
opinions. Simultaneously variable profitability, liquidity, audit lag, and prior opinion have an
influence on the opinion of audit going concern. Logistic regression tests show the quality of
audits against audit opinions has a significant influence. The results of the track analysis prove
that audit quality variables cannot mediate profitability variables, liquidity, lag audits, as well
as prior opinions on audit opinions going concerns in textile and garment companies listed on
the Indonesia Stock Exchange for the period 2015-2019.
Therefore, the company is expected to maximize its performance and products so that the
company can continue to grow and the expected financial statements also remain stable. One
of the things that can have an impact on audit opinion going concern is profitability and prior
opinion (audit opinion of the previous year), then the company must take effective steps in
accordance with the company's conditions in order to maintain its business continuity properly.
Audits Quality in Mediating Profitability, Liquidity, Audit Lag, Prior Opinion on Accepting Going Concern
Audits
1012 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(8), May 2022
REFERENCES
Anita, Widya Febryari. (2017). ANALISIS FAKTOR-FAKTOR YANG MEMPENGARUHI
OPINI AUDIT GOING CONCERN PADA PERUSAHAAN MANUFAKTUR YANG
TERDAFTAR DI BURSA EFEK INDONESIA. Jurnal Riset Keuangan Dan Akuntansi,
3(2). https://doi.org/10.25134/jrka.v3i2.939
Aria, Oleh, & Pasaribu, Masdiana. (2015). Pengaruh Kualitas Auditor, Likuiditas, Solvabilitas
Dan Profitabilitas Terhadap Opini Audit Going Concern Pada Sub Sektor Makanan Dan
Minuman Yang Terdaftar Di Bursa Efek Indonesia. Agusuts, 6(2).
Ghozali, Imam. (2018). Aplikasi analisis multivariate dengan program IBM SPSS 25 (9th ed.).
Semarang: Universitas Diponegoro.
Herianti, Eva, & Suryani, Arna. (2016). Pengaruh Kualitas Auditor , Audit Delay dan Audit
Tenure Terhadap Kualitas Audit Perbankan yang Terdaftar di BEI Periode 2012-2014.
Prosiding Seminar Nasional INDOCOMPAC.
Kasmir. (2015). Analisis laporan keuangan. Jakarta: Raja Grafindo Persada.
Krissindiastuti, Monica, & Rasmini, Ni Ketut. (2016). Faktor-faktor yang mempengaruhi opini
audit going concern. E-Jurnal Akuntansi Universitas Udayana, 14(1), 451–481.
Kurbani, Adie, Heryati, Heryati, & Rismansyah, Rismansyah. (2019). Analisis Likuiditas Dan
Profitabilitas Melalui Variabel Intervening Kualitas Audit Terhadap Opini Auidt Going
Concern Pada Perusahaan Manufaktur Yang Terdaftar Di Bursa Efek Indonesia. JURNAL
MANAJEMEN DAN BISNIS SRIWIJAYA, 17(1).
https://doi.org/10.29259/jmbs.v17i1.8943
Nugroho, Lucky, Nurrohmah, Siti, & Anasta, Lawe. (2018). FAKTOR-FAKTOR YANG
MEMPENGARUHI OPINI AUDIT GOING CONCERN. Jurnal SIKAP (Sistem
Informasi, Keuangan, Auditing Dan Perpajakan), 2(2).
https://doi.org/10.32897/sikap.v2i2.79
Risamasu, Inez Cornelia, & Christiawan, Yulius Jogi. (2017). FAKTOR–FAKTOR YANG
MEMPENGARUHI OPINI AUDIT GOING CONCERN. Business Accounting Review,
5(2), 193–204.
Safitri, Riza. (2017). Pengaruh Kondisi Keuangan Perusahaan, Ukuran Perusahaan, Opinion
Shopping, Kualitas Audit, Audit Client Tenure, Debt Default, dan Audit Lag terhadap
Penerimaan Opini Audit Going Concern. JOM Fekon, 4(1).