P-ISSN: 2808-0467
E-ISSN: 2808-5051
Homepage: https://iss.internationaljournallabs.com/index.php/iss
1128 This work is licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0
THE RISK MANAGEMENT OF THE BOGOR-SUKABUMI CROSS-
RAIL DUAL-TRACK CONSTRUCTION PROJECT ON TIME
CONTROL
Edwin Moerdianto
*
, Fitri Suryani, Dwi Dinariana
Master of Civil Engineering, Persada Indonesia Y.A.I University, Central Jakarta, DKI Jakarta, Indonesia
*
edwin.moerdianto@gmail.com
PAPER INFO ABSTRACT
Received: April
2022
Revised: May
2022
Approved: May
2022
Background: The implementation of risk management is very important to
do to reduce the occurrence of risks in the implementation. In the
implementation of work, unmanaged risks can have an impact on not
achieving the targets of the completion plan according to the planned time.
Aim: This study aims to find out how to identify the dominant risk of time
delays in the implementation of the Bogor-Sukabumi Cross Railway Double
Track Construction and its handling strategies.
Method: The research conducted is descriptive research. Primary data were
collected by the method of checklist analysis from the literature, risk
management of similar activity projects or previous studies, then identified
the risks. Meanwhile, the secondary data in the form of a plan map for the
Bogor-Sukabumi Railway double-track route is needed as secondary data to
obtain information, project descriptions, implementation methods and the
time needed to complete the construction obtained from the West Java
Railway Engineering Center.
Findings: The dominant risk factors that can affect performance, there are 5
risk factors, namely avalanches in the implementation of work, cost overruns
related to changes and additions to work, design not in accordance with field
conditions (Planning constraints), constraints related to working hours with
residents around the site, and delays in obtaining planning approval.
KEYWORDS
risk management, Bogor-Sukabumi cross-rail dual-track construction project, time
control
INTRODUCTION
Indonesia is currently intensively carrying out development, especially related to
infrastructure. Infrastructure development has a significant position in supporting economic
development, regional development and as a unifying indonesian region (Silondae, 2016). One
of the infrastructure developments that is being intensified is railways.
Railways are an important and strategic mode of transportation in achieving and
strengthening the resilience of a nation as a regional link (Transportation of people and mass
cargo), supporting the improvement of the people's economy, regional economic growth and
national stability (Istianto et al., 2019). The strategic function of railways as a modeof
transportation in general is the function of driving, driving and supporting, national
development while in particular it is one of the driving forces of development and economy at
the domestic level (Dwiatmoko, 2018).
West Java, especially Bogor and Sukabumi, has a strategic role, namely as a production
and processing line for produce. For this reason, adequate infrastructure development support
is needed to support the smooth flow of people, goods, and services. The railway transportation
system is the answer in supporting the national transportation system where this transportation
The Risk Management of the Bogor-Sukabumi Cross-Rail Dual-Track Construction Project on Time Control
1129 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(8), May 2022
system has various advantages over other land transportation systems including mass
transportation, fast, energy-saving, effective and efficient transportation.
The development of the double track railway between Bogor-Sukabumi was carried out to
increase service capacity and facilitate train travel by making the railway road double.
Development of railway facilities and infrastructure, especially in areas with dense
transportation volumes. The construction of the existing line construction Between Batutulis -
Ciomas between Bogor - Sukabumi is part of the Railway Development program between
Bogor - Sukabumi which was launched as a form of government responsibility for the needs
of passenger and freight transportation to ensure a safe and timely train journey.
Through Law number 23 of 2007 concerning Railways, it is explained that railways as a
mode of transportation in the national transportation system have the characteristics of mass
transportation and certain advantages, cannot be separated from other modes of transportation,
the potential requires development and improvement of its function for regional liaisons, both
national and international, to support, urge, and drive national development to improve the
welfare of the people. In relation to the implementation of the development of the national
transportation network and the National Railway Master Plan, the Directorate General of
Railways has a planning for the construction of a railway double track in Bogor-Sukabumi with
a total length plan of ± 57,215 km.
The Construction Construction Process of the Existing Line Construction Between
Batutulis - Ciomas Lintas Bogor - Sukabumi is carried out with the multiyears contract
mechanism financed by State Sharia Securities (SBSN) for the 2019-2022 fiscal year. To
support the purpose of implementation, the railway is in accordance with the mandate of law
number 23 of 2007 concerning Railways, to reconstitute the implementation of national
railways as a whole. The arrangement for the implementation of railways is stated in the
National Railway Master Plan (RIPNAS) issued by the Directorate General of Railways of the
Ministry of Transportation in 2011. RIPNAS which is the basis and guidelines that underlie all
policies in the management and operation of national railways.
Each stage of the project cannot be separated from the risks and uncertainties that can
occur and affect both in terms of quality and quantity. The construction of the Double Railway
J ulur can occur delays from the contract time limit, if the provider does notanticipate the risks
that may occur and good implementation methods to minimize the risks that can occur.
Theimplementation of risk management is very important to do to reduce the occurrence of
risks in the implementation.
In the implementation of work, unmanaged risks can have an impact on not achieving the
targets of the completion plan according to the planned time. Therefore, this study aims to find
out how to identify the dominant risk of time delays in the implementation of the Bogor-
Sukabumi Cross Railway Double Track Construction and its handling strategies. In addition,
this research is also expected to meet the research gap from previous studies as stated in the
following table.
The Risk Management of the Bogor-Sukabumi Cross-Rail Dual-Track Construction Project on Time Control
1130 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(8), May 2022
Table 1. Relevant Previous Research
Name
Title
Year
Method
Lu et al (2010)
Risk assessment model for
the railway reconstruction
project in Taiwan
2010
Using FMCDM that combines
multiple criteria decision
making (MCDM) fuzzy set
techniques and theory
Habibie (2017)
Time and Cost Risk
Analysis on the Makassar -
Parepare route railway
construction project
2017
Method
research with a cross-sectional
or cross-sectional approach
Li Qing et al.
(2014)
Quality Risk Management
Model for Railway
Construction Projects
2014
Metode menggunakan “A
Figure and Four Tables”
(AFFTM)
Marantika et al.
(2017)
Investment Risk Analysis of
Jakarta Bandung High-
Speed Train Project
2017
Monte Carlo Simulation
Methods
Trismara (2011)
Risk management on line
construction projects
coal railway in Central
Kalimantan with private
government cooperation
scheme
2011
Metode AHP (Analytical
Hierarchi Process)
METHOD
The research conducted is a descriptive study, which collects in detail information to
explain existing symptoms, identify problems, and investigate applicable conditions and
practices (Sugiyono, 2019). In this study, researchers identified the factors causing delays by
identifying the risk of delays in railway double-track construction projects and the impact of
delays in project construction, understanding the causes and consequences of delays, and
conducting risk analysis of the frequency of events and the impact of delays on railway double-
track construction.
Primary data were collected by the method of checklist analysis from the literature, risk
management of similar activity projects or previous studies, then identified the risks. The
results of the literature study were verified and pilot surveyed to experts by means of interviews
and questionnaires to identify relevant risks based on assessments by experts and conducting
questionnaire tests to respondents. Meanwhile, the secondary data in the form of a double-track
route plan map for the Bogor-Sukabumi Fire route is needed as secondary data to obtain
information, project descriptions, implementation methods and the time needed to complete
the construction obtained from the West Java Regional Railway Engineering Center.
The respondent population is a contractor who carries out the construction work of the
Cross Bogor-Sukabumi railway double track. The questionnaire data was processed using a
The Risk Management of the Bogor-Sukabumi Cross-Rail Dual-Track Construction Project on Time Control
1131 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(8), May 2022
frequency distribution approach and data processing with AHP (Analytical Hierarchy Process)
to produce significant priority factors.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Determination of Dominant Risk
Risk Ranking is the result of time-based data processing carried out during the data
analysis phase using the risk factor equation. The risk factor equation is defined as the
multiplication between the magnitude of the impact and the probability of occurrence of a risk
event (Pusjatan, 2005). Based on the results of the risk of determining the level of risk of work
that has a risk category, the level of high probability of occurrence and large impacts according
to table 2.
Table 2. High Risk Sequence
Types of Risks
Risk Factors
Category
The design does not match the conditions of the
field (planning constraints)
0.6725
High
Delays in obtaining planning approval
0.6615
High
The occurrence of avalanches in the
implementation of work
0.6756
High
Cost overruns associated with job changes and
additions
0.6754
High
Constraints related to working hours with residents
around the location
0.6697
High
Source: Self-Processed Products
1) According to the results of the study, there are 5 dominant risk factors that can affect
performance, sorted according to the highest ranking, namely the occurrence of
avalanches in the implementation of work (X29);
2) Cost overruns related to changes and additions to jobs (X30);
3) The design does not match the field conditions (planning constraints) (X6);
4) Constraints related to working hours with residents around the location (X43);
5) Delay in obtaining planning approval (X8).
Related to the impact of the dominant risk needs to be managed or mitigated, experts
provide opinions and opinions freely and objectively, and can even revise their previous
opinions. So that the results of the discussion obtained can be as flexible as possible.
Dominant Risks Discussion
After the dominant risk is obtained, the next stage validates the results that have been
obtained. Validation is processed using the Delphi method to get consensus from experts, so
that opinions on dominant risks are known that have a negative influence on project time
performance.
Before determining the actions that must be taken against the dominant risk is expert input
related to mitigating and handling the high risk of research results. The interview was
The Risk Management of the Bogor-Sukabumi Cross-Rail Dual-Track Construction Project on Time Control
1132 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(8), May 2022
conducted only on 4 experts which was carried out on March 2, 8, 9 and 21, 2022, the exact
results of the interview were obtained in table 7.
Table 3. Dominant Risk Mitigation
Risk
Cause
Impact
Recommendations
Risk
Division
Risk
Mitigation
Preventive
Corrective
The oc-
currenc
e of
ava-
lanches
in the
imple-
menta-
tion of
work
1) Nature
where the
intensity of
rainfall is
high during
the imple-
mentation
causes the
cliff soil to
become
soft and
unstable
with a
fairly steep
slope an-
gle. Ac-
cording to
morpho-
logical
data, soil
types in-
clude
young
rocks that
are prone to
landslides;
2) Extreme
weather
conditions
and field
situations
and high
groundwa-
ter levels
cause un-
stable soils
and land-
slides;
3) Poor water
manage-
ment of
residential
drainage
channels
resulted in
1) Gives a
bad im-
age of
how the
planning
and exe-
cution of
the work
is carried
out;
2) Delayed
imple-
menta-
tion of
the work
because a
study
must be
carried
out to
find the
source of
the prob-
lem of
ava-
lanche;
3) For the
contrac-
tor, there
is an
overhead
because it
will make
a replace-
ment if
the re-
sults of
the study
are an er-
ror of the
contrac-
tor's im-
plemen-
tation
method
1) The con-
tractor
supervises
and
sterilizes
the area
where
there is
cladding
and the
installa-
tion of
safety
lines and
signs
prohibited
from
passing
through
the work
area;
2) The con-
tractor has
relocated
5 houses
of the af-
fected
residents
by provid-
ing tem-
porary
residential
facilities
to avoid
the risk if
there is a
landslide
again until
the land
protection
is com-
pleted and
declared
safe by
1) The con-
tractor
closed
the
structure
and
cliffs
tempo-
rarily in
Cipaku
by using
a tarpau-
lin to re-
duce the
ingress
of water
in the
av-
alanche
area;
2) The con-
tractor
erected a
tempo-
rary
steel
sheet
pile on
the DPT
and
CCSP
landslid
e cliffs
in
Cipaku
as a soil
treatmen
t to
mini-
mize
soil
move-
ment;
3) The con-
tractor
1) The con-
tractor
will bear
the work
that has
failed
construc
tion if
the
planning
and
drawing
s are in
ac-
cordance
with the
imple-
menta-
tion but
the im-
plemen-
tation is
wrong.
Mean-
while, if
there is
an error
in the de-
sign, it
will be
borne by
the
Owner
(PPK)
and PPK
conducts
a tech-
nical
study for
handling
the ava-
lanche
area with
the help
1) Apart
from con-
struction
work, co-
ordinat-
ing with
ppk land
related to
land limi-
tations
with the
aim of re-
ducing
the bur-
den of
slopes
due to
residen-
tial areas
and in-
vetariza-
tion of ar-
eas that
are in-
cluded in
landslide-
prone ar-
eas that
need to be
relocated
perma-
nently by
purchas-
ing resi-
dents'
property
so that the
burden
from set-
tlements
can be re-
moved
and re-
duced;
The Risk Management of the Bogor-Sukabumi Cross-Rail Dual-Track Construction Project on Time Control
1133 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(8), May 2022
Risk
Cause
Impact
Recommendations
Risk
Division
Risk
Mitigation
Preventive
Corrective
soft slope
soils;
4) Factors
caused by
the imple-
mentation
of the work
in the form
of vibra-
tions from
the borpile
equipment
used can
cause ava-
lanches to
occur.
and if the
fault of
the owner
will be an
increase
in the
cost of
carrying
out the
work;
4) The land-
slide had
an impact
on the
collapse
of the soil
barrier in
the form
of a 20-
meter-
long
CCSP;
5) The
CCSP in-
stallation
work in
Cipaku is
not in ac-
cordance
with the
schedule
of the in-
stallation
plan be-
cause it is
waiting
for the
results of
a study
from a
planning
consult-
ant re-
lated to
the con-
struction
that will
be used
along the
the plan-
ning con-
sultant;
and
3) PPK has
assigned
the task of
an In-
dependent
consultant
to make a
technical
study of
the further
handling
of
landslide
incidents
in Cipaku.
carried
out
security
and
evacua-
tion of
residents
whose
homes
were at
the loca-
tion
where
the cliff
ava-
lanche
occurre.
of an In-
depend-
ent con-
sultant;
2) If the
work has
been
signed
by the
exe-
cuting
party of
the
work,
then the
responsi
bility is
by the
execut-
ing
party.
2) Related to
con-
struction
requires
input and
opinions
from in-
depend-
ent con-
sultants
for ava-
lanche
handling;
3) Carry out
avalanche
preven-
tion by
mapping
and iden-
tifying lo-
cations
that have
soil con-
ditions
prone to
ava-
lanches;
4) The exec-
utor of
the work
must
identify
all risks
that will
occur,
and es-
tablish
preven-
tive
measures,
imple-
mented
and su-
pervised
and eval-
uated pri-
odically.
The Risk Management of the Bogor-Sukabumi Cross-Rail Dual-Track Construction Project on Time Control
1134 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(8), May 2022
Risk
Cause
Impact
Recommendations
Risk
Division
Risk
Mitigation
Preventive
Corrective
ava-
lanche.
The de-
sign
does
not
match
the
con-
ditions
of the
field
(plan-
ning
con-
straints)
1) The target
time for
complet-
ing a short
planning
document
(lack of
time) the
planning
consultant
conducts a
survey in
the field
so that the
topo-
graphical
data, mor-
phology,
utilities
and func-
tions are
located
(cultural
heritage
data) so
that the
data ob-
tained are
incom-
plete and
also result
in limita-
tions in
consulting
with the
owner and
related
parties;
2) Availabil-
ity of costs
to
accommo-
date the
number of
expert
personnel
in accord-
ance with
1) PPK con-
ducts de-
sign re-
views re-
lated to
designs
that are
not in ac-
cordance
with the
condi-
tions in
the field
with re-
lated par-
ties such
as PDAM
so that
rail work
can be
known to
remain or
shift its
position,
so that
the pro-
vider re-
sched-
ules;
2) The oc-
currence
of addi-
tional
costs and
time due
to
changes
in design
or con-
struction
due to
shifts in
job posi-
tions;
3) Changes
in imple-
menta-
tion
1) PPK en-
sures from
the begin-
ning of
the con-
tract by
lowering
the meas-
urement
team from
the initial
KM to the
final KM
to obtain
data and
ensure
that plan-
ning doc-
uments
such as
DED,
technical
drawings,
bill off
quantity
are in
accord-
ance with
the con-
ditions in
the field;
2) PPK be-
fore the
imple-
mentation
of the
work
coordi-
nates with
the design
consultant
to cross-
check the
existing
data by
conduct-
ing a field
survey
1) The con-
tractor
coordi-
nates
with
PPK, su-
pervisor
y
consult-
ants
with
planning
consult-
ants to
re-plan
the
changes
that oc-
cur be-
cause
the
design
does not
match
the
current
field
con-
ditions
and
changes
in the
work
schedule
;
2) The con-
tractor
checks
or
checks
the data
that will
be used
as the
basis for
the
design
by
1) The con-
tractor
bears the
risk of
time be-
cause it
has to
wait for
the inap-
propriate
design to
be re-
viewed
again
until it is
ap-
proved;
2) It affects
the con-
tractor
and KDP
and can
involve
planners
as well
because
there is a
possibil-
ity that
design
changes
will
change
the vol-
ume,
cost and
draw-
ings. If
changes
to the de-
sign are
deemed
major
then the
contrac-
tor will
coordi-
nate with
1) Conduct-
ing a pre-
liminary
examina-
tion of
the docu-
ment by
conduct-
ing MC 0
and fo-
cusing on
primary
data and
second-
ary data
as docu-
ments in
the prep-
aration of
planning
for the
Direc-
torate of
Infra-
structure
to recruit
the Con-
stitu-
tional
Court to
carry out
special
designs;
2) Conduct-
ing test-
ing and
re-meas-
urement
by re-
drilling
by sam-
pling at
the work
location
to ensure
the con-
struction
design is
The Risk Management of the Bogor-Sukabumi Cross-Rail Dual-Track Construction Project on Time Control
1135 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(8), May 2022
Risk
Cause
Impact
Recommendations
Risk
Division
Risk
Mitigation
Preventive
Corrective
the quali-
fication
needs for
the prepa-
ration of
planning
docu-
ments;
3) Often
planners
do not see
the loca-
tion and
only re-
ceive data
on previ-
ous site
surveys,
where the
data used
has not
updated
the latest
field con-
ditions;
4) The valid-
ity and re-
ality of the
data are
less trust-
worthy as
inputs in
the prepa-
ration of
the design.
methods
and the
addition
of new
material
items
such as
sheetpile
to hold
soil slides
on the
PDAM
line
above the
track,
during
the in-
stallation
of CCSP;
4) The work
cannot be
done be-
cause it is
not in ac-
cordance
with field
condi-
tions so
that it
must be
reviewed
or rede-
signed
and re-
lated to
the de-
sign will
take a
long time
where the
construc-
tion de-
sign
needs to
be
checked
and re-
calcu-
lated
based on
whether
the data
obtained
is in ac-
cordance
with the
construc-
tion de-
sign;
3) Primary
and sec-
ondary
data in the
prep-
aration of
the design
must be
valid and
reliable
where the
design is
tested first
before be-
ing ap-
plied.
compar-
ing the
condi-
tions in
the field.
For
track
work
carried
out, it
can be
done
testing
the
taking
per 25 to
50 m;
and
3) Tri-
anggula-
tion,
namely
by using
a dual
design
or multi
method
to over-
come
planning
obstacle
s
the su-
pervisor
y
consult-
ant to
ask the
KDP to
call the
planning
consult-
ant to re-
design
the plan-
ning.
As for
PPK,
there
will be
many
proposal
s for de-
sign
changes
from us-
ers who
want to
imple-
ment
new
activities
where
the role
of PPK
de-
termines
the de-
sign ac-
cording
to the re-
sults of
the con-
sultant's
review;
and
3) The
owner of
the
work,
but if the
work has
appropri-
ate at the
time of
MC 0;
and
3) Conduct-
ing a
field re-
view,
then ana-
lyzed and
evaluated
all the
plans that
have
been de-
termined,
to find
out the
existing
biases. If
it is
found
that there
are very
signifi-
cant dif-
ferences,
then
make im-
prove-
ments or
revisions
to all the
plans that
have al-
ready
been
drawn
up.
The Risk Management of the Bogor-Sukabumi Cross-Rail Dual-Track Construction Project on Time Control
1136 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(8), May 2022
Risk
Cause
Impact
Recommendations
Risk
Division
Risk
Mitigation
Preventive
Corrective
field con-
ditions.
been
signed
the con-
tract by
the exe-
cuting
party of
the
work,
then the
responsi
bility is
on the
side of
the job
manager
Con-
straints
related
to
work-
ing
hours
with
resi-
dents
around
the lo-
cation
1) The con-
struction
site of the
railway
close to
the settle-
ment be-
came an
obstacle
when car-
rying out
overtime
work;
2) Citizen
protests
related to
the noise
of borpile
machines,
vibration
pollution
and air
pollution
for the in-
stallation
of CCSPs;
and
3) Lack of
socializa-
tion and
approach
to local
residents
1) The lim-
ited hours
of work
adapt to
the cul-
ture of
the resi-
dents
around
the loca-
tion;
2) The oc-
currence
of com-
pensation
costs that
must be
given to
affected
residents,
for exam-
ple, there
are resi-
dents'
houses
that are
cracked
due to vi-
bration
due to the
use of
heavy
equip-
ment;
1) Take per-
suasive
actions by
social-
izing and
coordi-
nating by
involving
officials
together
with the
village,
and the
commu-
nity
around the
location
of the
con-
struction
of the
railway
line which
has an
impact to
get input
related to
working
hours in
the project
using
heavy
equip-
ment;
1) Resched
uling by
carrying
out each
stage of
work
correctly
and
accelerat
ing
CCSP
work by
adding
borpile
equip-
ment
and
stake
tools;
and
2) Compen
sation
and so-
cializa-
tion by
involvin
g
commu-
nity
insti-
tutions
and resi-
dents
around
1) The
owner
and
executor
of the
work;
2) PPK co-
ordinate
s with
con-
tractors,
consult-
ants and
commu-
nity
insti-
tutions
(RT,
RW) and
the sur-
rounding
commu-
nity to
conduct
media-
tion.
Contrac-
tors re-
lated to
equip-
ment
work
time
cannot
1) Before
the work
is con-
tracted to
a third
party, the
owner of
the work
must
carry out
socializa-
tion and
approach
the com-
munity
and the
govern-
ment ap-
parat at
the job
location
about the
work im-
plemen-
tation
plan in-
cluding
the work-
ing time.
Like-
wise, af-
ter the
work is
handed
The Risk Management of the Bogor-Sukabumi Cross-Rail Dual-Track Construction Project on Time Control
1137 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(8), May 2022
Risk
Cause
Impact
Recommendations
Risk
Division
Risk
Mitigation
Preventive
Corrective
and offi-
cials.
3) The im-
plemen-
tation of
the work
was late
imple-
mented
with the
plan.
2) Socialize
with resi-
dential
residents
around the
job site
and
involve
influential
residents
to be part
of the
work to
reduce
social im-
pact;
3) Permits
from local
govern-
ments,
socialize
the com-
munity
and local
officials
about the
work to be
carried
out
the work
to obtain
agree-
ment on
working
hours.
be
maxim-
ized at
the time
of imple-
menta-
tion of
overtime
changin
g work
methods
; and
3) The con-
tractor
was ac-
compa-
nied by
the
owner
for so-
cializa-
tion ac-
tivities at
the be-
ginning
of the
work in
coordina
tion with
the Po-
lice,
Koramil,
commu-
nity
insti-
tutions
and resi-
dents.
over to a
third
party, the
imple-
menting
party
takes the
same ap-
proach
and so-
cializa-
tion;
2) Conduct-
ing so-
cializa-
tion and
coordina-
tion at the
begin-
ning of
work re-
lated to
the use of
boorpile
equip-
ment
used in
the im-
plemen-
tation of
work and
agree-
ments on
time; and
3) Write to
the Po-
lice,
Koramil,
Ke-
lurahan
and res-
idents to
socialize
and
coordi-
nate at
the be-
ginning
of the
work to
The Risk Management of the Bogor-Sukabumi Cross-Rail Dual-Track Construction Project on Time Control
1138 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(8), May 2022
Risk
Cause
Impact
Recommendations
Risk
Division
Risk
Mitigation
Preventive
Corrective
get an
agree-
ment on
working
time.
Delays
in ob-
taining
plan-
ning
ap-
proval
1) The data
used is in-
complete
and the ac-
curacy of
the data is
not precise
so that the
approval
is too late;
2) The study
of the pro-
posed
topic or
material is
less valid
and re-
quires
sharpen-
ing;
3) There has
been no
delegation
from the
Direc-
torate re-
garding
planning
approval
or levels
such as the
plan to de-
molish the
warehouse
at STA. 4
+ 350 and
the rede-
sign of the
Batu Tulis
station
emplace-
ment that
has not
1) The im-
plementa
tion of
activities
will be
late and
may af-
fect the
increase
in the
cost of
activities;
2) The im-
plementa
tion of
activities
on the
slate
station
emplace-
ment has
not been
able to be
carried
out pend-
ing the
results of
the rede-
sign ap-
proved
by the
Tech-
nical Di-
rectorate;
and
3) The work
that will
be carried
out be-
comes
back-
wards
and
schedule
1) Discus-
sions are
carried
out with
contrac-
tors and
consult-
ants after
the results
of the
study are
obtained,
the con-
tractor is
allowed to
make
material
acquisi-
tions and
simulta-
neous
presenta-
tion of the
design re-
sults with
the Direc-
torate of
Infra-
structure
to obtain
design re-
view ap-
proval;
2) The con-
tractor
coordi-
nates with
the
planning
team re-
garding
the work
to be car-
ried out
1) The con-
tractor
coordi-
nates
with the
KDP to
obtain
certainty
of the re-
sults of
the rede-
sign
when
approval
can be
obtained
to carry
out other
work in
parallel
with the
work
that has
received
approval
;
2) The con-
tractor
coordi-
nates
with the
KDP re-
garding
the valid
data of
the work
to be
used in
the im-
ple-
menta-
tion of
the
1) The
Owner
or
assignor
of the
Job.
Through
out the
re-
sponsibil
ity of the
owner,
an
extensio
n of time
is carried
out and
the Con-
tractor
has to re-
schedule
and for
redesign
work.
PPK
coor-
dinates
with
planners,
con-
tractors
and con-
sultants
to
accelerat
e the
com-
pletion
of the
rede-
sign; and
2) The con-
tractor
1) The con-
tractor
coordi-
nates
with the
KDP en-
suring
the com-
pletion of
planning
ap-
provals
to rear-
range the
work
schedule;
2) As soon
as possi-
ble, ask
the Di-
rectorate
of Infra-
structure
for time
to be able
to receive
the KDP
for an ex-
pose to
get sug-
gestions
and input
for the
accelera-
tion of
Design
approval;
3) Prepare a
complete
and valid
planning
docu-
ment,
explain
The Risk Management of the Bogor-Sukabumi Cross-Rail Dual-Track Construction Project on Time Control
1139 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(8), May 2022
Risk
Cause
Impact
Recommendations
Risk
Division
Risk
Mitigation
Preventive
Corrective
been in-
cluded in
the PPK
implement
ation doc-
ument co-
ordinates
and ob-
tains the
approval
of the
West Java
BTP Head
of The
BTP Cen-
ter but still
has to wait
for ap-
proval
from the
Direc-
torate.
changes
are made
which re-
sults in
contrac-
tor ex-
penses
becomin
g bloated
due to the
mobiliza-
tion of
tools and
workers.
by in-
volving a
team that
under-
stands the
substance
planned
from the
begin-
ning;
3) The con-
tractor re-
schedules,
tem-
porarily,
or does
other
work so
that there
is no job
vacancy
when this
risk oc-
curs ;
4) Complete
the data
needed
supported
by the
correct
field sur-
vey re-
sults;
5) Engages a
team that
un-
derstands
the
planned
substance
from the
start
work;
and
3) Dis-
cussing
the
planned
material
with
compe-
tent ex-
perts
and col-
lecting
more
valid
data by
sched-
uling
consul-
tations
with the
tech-
nical
direc-
torate.
will re-
quest an
extensio
n of the
imple-
menta-
tion time
because
the work
docu-
ments
have not
yet re-
ceived
ap-
proval.
and dis-
cuss it to
the party
who will
approve.
Cost
over-
runs as-
soci-
ated
with
job
changes
1) The lack
of good
planning
con-
sultants in
carrying
out
preliminar
1) Addition
al costs
that will
be borne
by the
owner
due to
project
1) It needs
opinions
and
opinions
from
design
consultant
s which
1) Choosin
g work
methods
that can
optimize
in the
field to
carry out
KDP and
Contractors
share risks
based on
their
objectivity,
for KDP
changes and
1) Mitigatio
n so that
financing
is not
swollen,
an ex-
aminatio
n of the
The Risk Management of the Bogor-Sukabumi Cross-Rail Dual-Track Construction Project on Time Control
1140 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(8), May 2022
Risk
Cause
Impact
Recommendations
Risk
Division
Risk
Mitigation
Preventive
Corrective
and
addi-
tions
y planning
(topogra-
phy, mor-
phology,
location
climate
and
situation)
that has
not been
carried out
compre-
hensively
at the
location of
the work
may need
to be
assessed
which pri-
orities
such as
flooding
cause the
baan body
to become
ablaze
even
though it
is clear
that the
soil study
is not well
located
while the
protective
buildings
on the
river are
not
consid-
ered and
budgeting
in the im-
plementa-
tion is not
included
in the
planning
planning
that is not
in ac-
cordance
with the
condition
s in the
field and
deter-
mining
the focus
of work
priorities
that af-
fect the
overall
work;
2) Resulting
in the
period of
imple-
mentatio
n of the
work be-
ing in-
creased
so that it
is
resched-
uled;
3) Financial
or eco-
nomic vi-
ability to
work
may
change
due to
changes
and addi-
tions to
employ-
ment.
work is
the most
priority so
that
imple-
mentation
and budg-
eting can
be more
efficient;
2) Recalcula
ting for
work that
has been
added is
not in ac-
cordance
with the
plan so
that the
amount of
overall
costs that
must be
incurred
by the
KDP is
obtained;
3) Reviewin
g the
design on
previous
planning
that is not
in accord-
ance with
the
current
conditions
of the site;
and
4) Planning
consultant
s carry out
planning
appropri-
ately, and
evaluate
each stage
of work
work
that can
be done
based on
budget-
ing
prior-
ities;
2) Perform
steps by
schedul-
ing and
studying
the de-
sign on
which
the work
is based
to deter-
mine the
work
methods
that can
be
carried
out; and
3) Conduct
ing a
sensitiv-
ity anal-
ysis in
planning
pro-
posals to
mini-
mize
changes
and ad-
ditional
costs.
additional
volumes of
work result
in additional
costs af-
fecting the
value of the
work
contract
while the
contractor
will affect
the timing of
work im-
plementa-
tion.
cal-
culated
cost
analysis
and the
use of
work
methods
are
carried
out
which
analysis
can be
more
efficient
and
effective;
2) The con-
tractor
conducts
a review
of the
work that
has
experi-
enced an
increase
or de-
crease in
work in
accord-
ance with
field con-
ditions;
and
3) Conduct
careful
planning
and sup-
ported by
accurate
and real-
iable data
The Risk Management of the Bogor-Sukabumi Cross-Rail Dual-Track Construction Project on Time Control
1141 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(8), May 2022
Risk
Cause
Impact
Recommendations
Risk
Division
Risk
Mitigation
Preventive
Corrective
calcu-
lations;
2) Lack of
data on the
timing of
planning
and pre-
liminary
design that
has not ac-
com-
modated
activities
that have
not been
included
in the
employ-
ment
contract;
and
3) Planning
errors, due
to the lack
of data
and
experts in
the
analysis of
work plan-
ning.
with ac-
curate
data
CONCLUSION
1) The dominant risk factors that can affect performance are the occurrence of avalanches
in the implementation of work, cost overruns related to changes and additions to work,
design not in accordance with field conditions (planning constraints), constraints
related to working hours with residents around the location, and delays in obtaining
planning approval ;
2) The form of mitigation of the dominant risk resulting from interviews with experts
obtained the following results:
a) The occurrence of avalanches in the implementation of work is:
1. Apart from construction work, coordinating with ppk land related to land
limitations with the aim of reducing the burden of slopes due to residential areas
and invetarization of areas that are included in landslide-prone areas that need
to be relocated permanently by purchasing residents' property so that the burden
from settlements can be removed and reduced;
The Risk Management of the Bogor-Sukabumi Cross-Rail Dual-Track Construction Project on Time Control
1142 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(8), May 2022
2. Related to construction requires input and opinions from independent
consultants for avalanche handling;
3. Carry out avalanche prevention by mapping and identifying locations that have
soil conditions prone to avalanches;
4. The executor of the work must identify all the risks that will occur, and establish
preventive measures, implemented and supervised and evaluated in acryodic
manner.
b) The cost overruns associated with job changes and additions (X30) are:
1. An examination of the calculated cost analysis and the use of work methods are
carried out which analysis can be more efficient and effective;
2. The contractor conducts a review of the work that has experienced an increase
or decrease in work in accordance with field conditions;
3. Carry out careful planning and supported by accurate and realiable data.
c) The design not in accordance with field conditions (planning constraints) (X6) is:
1. Conducting a preliminary examination of the document by conducting MC 0
and focusing on primary data and secondary data as documents in the
preparation of planning for the Directorate of Infrastructure to recruit the
Constitutional Court to carry out special designs;
2. Conducting testing and re-measurement by re-drilling by sampling at the work
location to ensure the construction design is appropriate at the time of MC 0;
and
3. Conducting a field review, then analyzed and evaluated all the plans that have
been determined, to find out the existing biases. If it is found that there are very
significant differences, then make improvements or revisions to all the plans
that have already been drawn up.
d) Constraints related to working hours with residents around the location (X43) are:
1. Before the work is contracted to a third party, the owner of the work must carry
out socialization and approach to the community, government officials at the
job site explain the plan for the implementation of the work including the
working time. Likewise, after the work is handed over to a third party, the
implementing party takes the same approach and socialization;
2. Conducting socialization and coordination at the beginning of work related to
the use of boorpile equipment used in the implementation of work and
agreements on time; and
3. Write to the Police, Koramil, Kelurahan and residents to socialize and
coordinate at the beginning of the work to get an agreement on working time.
e) Delays in obtaining planning approval are:
1. The contractor coordinates with the KDP ensuring the completion of planning
approvals to rearrange the work schedule;
2. As soon as possible, ask the Directorate of Infrastructure for time to be able to
receive the KDP for an expose to get suggestions and input for the acceleration
of Design approval;
3. Prepare a complete and valid planning document, explain and discuss it to the
party who will approve.
The Risk Management of the Bogor-Sukabumi Cross-Rail Dual-Track Construction Project on Time Control
1143 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(8), May 2022
REFERENCES
Dwiatmoko, H. (2018). Peran Transportasi Perkeretaapian: Dalam Pembangunan Nasional
Melalui Analisis Input-Output. Kencana.
Habibie, Y. R. (2017). Analisis Risiko Waktu Dan Biaya Pada Proyek Konstruksi Jalur Kereta
Api Rute Makassar-Parepare [Doctoral Dissertation]. Institut Teknologi Sepuluh
Nopember.
Istianto, B., Suharti, E., Noviyanti, N., & Ismaryati, E. (2019). Transportasi Jalan di Indonesia:
Sejarah dan Perkembangannya. Melvana Publishing.
Lu, S.-T., Kuo, Y.-C., & Yu, S.-H. (2010). Risk assessment model for the railway
reconstruction project in Taiwan. 2010 International Conference on Machine Learning
and Cybernetics, 2, 1017–1022.
Marantika, D., Erwinsyah, M. B., Hatmoko, J. U. D., & Khasani, R. R. (2017). Analisis Risiko
Investasi Proyek Kereta Cepat Jakarta-Bandung. Jurnal Karya Teknik Sipil, 6(1), 324–
335.
Pusjatan. (2005). Pedoman penilaian resiko investasi jalan tol Bandung. Pusjatan.
Qing, L. I., Rengkui, L. I. U., Jun, Z., & Quanxin, S. U. N. (2014). Quality risk management
model for railway construction projects. Procedia Engineering, 84, 195–203.
Silondae, S. (2016). Keterkaitan jalur transportasi dan interaksi ekonomi Kabupaten Konawe
Utara dengan kabupaten/kota sekitarnya [Doctoral Dissertation]. Haluoleo University.
Sugiyono. (2019). Metode penelitian kuantitatif, kualitatif, dan R&D. Alfabeta.
Trismara, R. N. (2011). Manajemen Risiko Proyek Pembangunan] alur KeretaApi Batubara di
Kalimantan Tengah Dengan Skema KPS (Kerjasama Pemerintah dan Swasta)(Tesis).
Fakultas Teknik Program Pascasarjana. Universitas Indonesia.