Voting Rights Position in Constitutional Review and Human Rights
74 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(2), November 2021
Voting Rights Limit
In setting voting rights restrictions, there are quite serious problems. This is related to the
unequal requirements applied for general elections and for electoral districts, while both are
elections for public office which are filled through elections involving the people. The
differentiation policy will create a gap in the treatment of citizens in elections if the policy is
not based on logical and objective reasons. Logical and objective standards in measuring the
application of policy differentiation are a difficult and sensitive task (Purwanto et al.,
2020). This is due to the fact that the measurement must be based on objective justification
which will depend on the values among society which can change depending on space and
time.
If it is related to the study of philosophical justice, the dilemma of determining the
measurement of tolerable differentiation can be answered. The objective measurement is to
avoid the occurrence of conditions where a group of people will take advantage, and some
other groups will be disadvantaged in terms of rights. In other words, the objective
measurement of the implementation of differentiation in principle is the proportionality of
implementation. Restrictions on the Right to be Voted In the history of Indonesian general
elections, the regulations limiting the right to vote are very dynamic. In such dynamics, there
are requirements that are consistently used, there are requirements that are applied but removed
at the next election, and there are new requirements to accommodate the needs of the day.
In the early general election period, the requirements to become a candidate are generally
no more than six elections. During the New Order regime, there were eleven conditions for
exercising the right to vote and three for being elected. These three requirements only apply to
candidates for president/vice president and regional heads/deputy heads. These requirements
do not apply to candidates for membership in the DPR, DPD, and DPRD. Meanwhile, the
legislative office, like the president, and the regional head are the same political office who are
elected through elections (Manurung, 2019).
With the same status of the offices, the three requirements should be similarly applied. As
candidates for public officials, candidates for members of the DPR, DPD, and DPRD must also
be given the obligation to report personal assets to the authorities, must have an NPWP, and
have an SPT. This requirement is important because paying taxes is a citizen's obligation, and
every candidate for public office must be a role model for other citizens in paying taxes. After
all, these requirements are several measures of a candidate's compliance with his duties in
serving the country (Zazili, 2016). In this regard, Mahfud MD is of the opinion that in the
absence of these requirements for candidates for members of the DPR, DPD, and DPRD
because these offices are representative offices, and these candidates for officials are not
always qualified as tax subjects.
On the other hand, executive officers are people who, because of their income, qualify as
tax subjects. In accordance with tax provisions, the obligation to have a NPWP only applies to
citizens, both individuals and legal entities whose income meets the minimum income tax
requirements. However, that is not the reason for the application of these three requirements
for candidates for DPR, DPD absolute. The requirements can still be adopted by certain
exceptions; mandatory requirements for candidates for members of the DPR, DPD, and DPRD
whose income is subject to tax (Ramadhanil et al., 2019). Meanwhile, for candidates whose