P-ISSN: 2808-0467
E-ISSN: 2808-5051
Homepage: https://iss.internationaljournallabs.com/index.php/iss
584 This work is licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0
APPLICATION OF THE KAIZEN METHOD IN EFFORTS TO
MAINTAIN THE SUSTAINABILITY OF SPRINGS IN INDONESIA
Ilham Muhammad
1
, Maya Aiko Salsabila Putri
2
, Husna Latifatul Karimah
3
, Gita Putri
Prastiwi
4
, Nur Himmatul Fitriyah
5
, Vicko Taniady
6
12
Geological Engineering, Diponergoro University, Indonesia
34
Chemical Engineering, Diponegoro University, Indonesia
5
Government Science, Brawijaya University, Indonesia
6
Law, University of Jember, Indonesia
1
ilhamats@students.undip.ac.id
2
maya.aikosalsabilaputri@gmail.com
3
husnalatifatul0@gmail.com
4
gitaputri1307@gmail.com
5
nurhimatul05@gmail.com
6
190710101184@mail.unej.ac.id
PAPER INFO ABSTRACT
Received:
December 2021
Revised:
February 2022
Approved:
February 2022
Background: Indonesia represents about 6% of the world's water sources.
This shows that Indonesia has abundant water resources. However, the facts
show that most areas of Indonesia experience a shortage of clean water
supplies. This is because the spring can be lost within a certain period if there
is no planning to maintain its availability. The solution offered is to fulfill
clean water needs with the Kaizen method. Kaizen is a 5S philosophy that
includes Seiri, Seinton, Seiso, Seiketsu, and Shitsuke.
Aim: This study aims to review the application of Kaizen methods and their
sustainability to be applied in Indonesia.
Method: The methods used in this study are descriptive observational are
aimed at describing and describing phenomena of a scientific and human
engineering nature.
Findings: The results of this study are packaged in the House Model. The
House Model is a tool used by an organization using a concept built to
transform into action. Some activities in the house model are tailored to meet
the needs of partners and further increase the efficiency and effectiveness of
the programs being implemented. The program also has good sustainability
in community aspects, regulations, and government.
KEYWORDS
Kaizen; springs in Indonesia; the house model
INTRODUCTION
Water is an essential component of human life, especially in meeting clean water needs
for households, industry, and public places. Along with increasing the need for clean water,
encouraging humans to continue to provide clean water with good standards of quality,
quantity, and continuity is worth using. Under the Sustainable Development Goals 6th point,
this is related to the guarantee of availability and sustainable management of clean water and
sanitation for all communities. Therefore, fulfilling clean water needs is a fundamental right of
the community that the government must provide.
Indonesia represents about 6% of the world's water sources. This shows that Indonesia has
abundant water resources. However, the facts show that most areas of Indonesia experience a
shortage of clean water supplies, such as in East Nusa Tenggara, Java, Bali, and Sulawesi
(Suryani, 2020). This is because the spring can be lost within a certain period if there is no
planning to maintain its availability. Even in 2018, the number of springs in Indonesia has
decreased by 20-40% within ten years (Maryati & Febriani, 2021). of the factors that affect the
decline of the spring are the source of the spring that dries up, the degradation of the catchment,
the lack of public concern for the efficiency of water use, and there is no sense of responsibility
Application of the Kaizen Method in Efforts to Maintain the Sustainability of Springs in Indonesia
585 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(5), Feb 2022
to maintain the spring. One of the areas threatened by the decline of springs is Drawati Village,
Paseh Subdistrict, Bandung Regency, which has 155 catchment wells with one spring.
However, this spring is threatened to disappear because its location is under the foot of Mount
Kasur, which has a very minimal amount of forest area so that the catchment area is threatened
to disappear. In addition, the lack of public knowledge related to the importance of maintaining
springs. This problem is exacerbated by the emergence of water tourism, resulting in decreased
cleanliness around the springs (Hasbiah & Kurniasih, 2019).
Efforts that have been made to maintain springs include taking a personal approach to the
surrounding community and issuing regulations to maintain the condition of springs and
catchment areas to stay well maintained (Ismawati, Rahayu, & Dewantari, 2020). In addition,
efforts made to fulfil clean water include making traditional digging wells and building clean
water reservoirs. However, these efforts can still not meet the needs of clean water of the
community. This is because the water coming from the digging well cannot be used for
drinking and cooking because the well water is cloudy and salty. In addition, efforts to build a
clean water reservoir require many funds, where; to build the tub, each family head must spend
IDR 25.000 each and from the fund can only make one reservoir (Jupri, Kusuma, Hidayat, &
Purnomo, 2015).
Based on the above problems, efforts are needed to meet the needs of clean water of the
community. The solution offered is to fulfill clean water needs with the Kaizen method. Kaizen
is a 5S philosophy that includes Seiri, Seinton, Seiso, Seiketsu, and Shitsuke. In Indonesia, the
Kaizen method is known as 5R. This Kaizen method has many advantages in increasing
motivation and positively affecting individuals and can create a new system with collaboration
and participation (Al Janahi, Zarreh, Wan, & Lee, 2019). In addition, the Kaizen method also
emphasizes minor improvements made continuously (Randhawa & Ahuja, 2017). In the
Kaizen method, maintenance measures need to be considered in achieving the expected goals.
Therefore, the Kaizen method is very suitable to be implemented as protection in
maintaining the availability of clean water for the community. The existence of water care with
the Kaizen method is expected to support the realization of SDGs 2030 point 11, namely
ensuring the availability and management of clean water that is sustainable and sanitation. This
is in line with the objectives of the Kaizen method, which focuses on continuous improvement
and optimization of management. In addition, this method also aims to increase public
knowledge and concern for clean water and empower the community in terms of recovery of
water management problems and other threats.
METHOD
In obtaining data in research, the method used is a qualitative descriptive method. The
descriptive method itself is a method that describes or describes an object or situation
objectively. Observational qualitative descriptive methods aim to describe phenomena of a
scientific and human engineering nature, which pay attention to the characteristics, qualities,
and interrelationships between activities (Atmowardoyo, 2018). In this study, the data used was
primary data and secondary data. The primary data is data obtained from the results of direct
observation in the field; data in the field is collected using observation techniques and
documentation techniques. Observations were carried out in several areas in Indonesia,
including Jabungan Village, Semarang City. Meanwhile, secondary data is obtained from
Application of the Kaizen Method in Efforts to Maintain the Sustainability of Springs in Indonesia
586 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(5), Feb 2022
literature studies in previous research journals on applying the previous Kaizen method. As for
data processing techniques, verification and triangulation techniques are used to check data
validity.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Using the Kaizen Method in Protecting Springs
The 5S program, also called the Kaizen method, is often used because it has some of the
suitable functions to implement to achieve a better direction. The 5S program (Seiri, Seiton,
Seiso, Seiketsu and Shitsuke) is the basis for the employee mentality to improve and realize
quality awareness (Carnerud, Jaca, & Bäckström, 2018). Companies are using the
establishment of the 5S program to maintain the spring's sustainability. If using this 5S
program, there will be several steps that can be done to maintain the sustainability of the spring.
The points are as follows:
1) Seiri/Sorting
The Seiri is the first step that can be done. At this stage, there needs to be a sorting
between those that will be reached or unused so that later it will be more concise.
Examples of implementation are as follows:
a) The holding of socialization to the community around the spring or certain
parties related knowledge to maintain the sustainability of the spring; and
b) Create a heating board around the spring about "do and don't" to match the
sustainability of the spring.
2) Seiton/Order
Seiton is concerned with arranging all goods regularly. This stage is an advanced stage
that can be done after the stage is over. The example of implementation is by making a
map of the spring area so that it can be known which areas can be accessed by the
community and which should not be accessed.
3) Seiso/Cleaning
Creating clean environmental conditions is undoubtedly critical to getting the desired
results. Examples of implementation are as follows:
a) Making a schedule for cleaning the area around the spring;
b) Complete the necessary cleaning equipment; and
c) Establish punishment for communities that make dirty areas of spring water.
4) Seiketsu/Maintanace
Caring for or maintaining achievements from previous stages or setting standards must
be met. Examples of implementation are as follows:
a) Scheduling to control hygiene checks.
b) Make an invitation through social media or platforms that are often visited by
the public related to the importance of maintaining the sustainability of the
spring.
c) Planting trees together around the spring area.
5) Shitsuke/Sustainability
Build self-discipline to get into the habit of implementing 5S programs through positive
habits and standardization. Examples of implementation are as follows:
Application of the Kaizen Method in Efforts to Maintain the Sustainability of Springs in Indonesia
587 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(5), Feb 2022
a) Open training for volunteer action in maintaining the continuity of the spring.
b) Close relationships with the community or partners to maintain the continuity
of the spring.
c) Conduct regular evaluations.
The Household Model Concept in Protecting Springs
The program's implementation adheres to the concept prepared using the house model. The
House Model is a tool used by an organization using a concept built to transform a dream into
action. Figure 1 will be explained The House Model.
Supporting Behavior
(Kaizen Method)
Sustainability of Springs
in Indonesia
Seiri/Sorting
Seiketsu/Maintenance
Shitsuke/Sustainability
Seiton/Order
Seiso/Cleaning
Figure 1. The House Model
According to Horovitz and Corbooz, there are three components to build promising
visions: dreams located on the rooftop, the pillar consists of the main methods to achieve this
vision, and the foundation is the primary indicator of improved performance the behaviour of
supporting factors. In this case, to maintain the sustainability of springs in Indonesia, a
community service program is implemented with the principle of the Kaizen Kaizen method
(Al Janahi et al., 2019).
The house model diagram shows that this program has five main concepts to realize the
research objectives: Seiri, Seiketsu, Shitsuke, Seiton, and Seiso. The five activities are the result
of the improvement approach. Some activities are tailored to meet the needs of partners and
further increase the efficiency and effectiveness of the programs being implemented.
Empowerment techniques that are carried out also collaborate with counselling, such as
providing material given to the community regarding the love of springs and methods of
managing springs. Then, training techniques were also carried out to make the community more
proactive in maintaining the springs, such as making signs and cleaning. Finally, there is a
mentoring technique: conducting FGD (Focus group discussion) to discuss future spring
management with various stakeholders (government, partners, and academics).
Application of the Kaizen Method in Efforts to Maintain the Sustainability of Springs in Indonesia
588 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(5), Feb 2022
Preventive and Curative Efforts
Preventive measures and curative actions help achieve goals and solve existing problems.
This preventive and curative action effort is reflected in the following points:
1) Seiri (Preventive): Seiri is the first step in sorting out information so that areas with the
potential of springs become efficient. So that, this preventive action involves finding
information and recognizing areas that have potential springs.
2) Seiton (Curative): Seiton is a step in structuring the spring area to be easy to use. So
that section is a corrective action in arranging and managing the spring with a sense of
responsibility.
3) Seiso (Curative): Action in the form of resuscitating the importance of maintaining
cleanliness at the source of the spring (figure 2).
4) Seiketsu (Preventive): Actions in the form of procedures to care for and maintain the
source of the spring.
5) Shitsuke (Preventive): The act of loving the existence of a spring.
Preventive measures such as Seiri, Seiketsu, and Shitsuke are carried out by seeking
information related to potential areas of spring so that the community can care for and maintain
the source of the spring so that there will be a sense of love for the existence of springs. In
implementing preventive measures, concrete actions are taken to counsel the importance of
spring and disseminate information using social media. This information will continue to be
updated, so little by little, it will make a significant impact on the broader community. While
in curative actions such as Seiton and Seiso, done by managing the spring with responsibility,
thus raising awareness in the community that the cleanliness of the spring is essential. In
implementing corrective actions, actual actions are carried out by cleaning the environment
around the springs and making warning signs around the springs. In addition, there is also the
idea of making a dam so that the spring's discharge does not decrease.
Figure 2. Seiso activity
Success in implementing preventive and curative measures will involve all surrounding
communities and open and change all people's minds that this 5S program is not just a program
but fosters a sense of community to maintain cleanliness around the springs.
Sustainability Program
The potential availability of clean water is increasingly reduced because the central and
local governments prioritize water catchment land for economic development rather than for
Application of the Kaizen Method in Efforts to Maintain the Sustainability of Springs in Indonesia
589 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(5), Feb 2022
environmental conservation. The rise of environmental pollution further exacerbates this. As
many as 70 million Indonesians still wastewater carelessly because they cannot access adequate
sanitation facilities (Fauziah & Internasional, 2021).
The Central Statistics Agency (BPS) shows that the achievement of access to drinking
water is 88%, while access to decent sanitation is in the position of 75%. From this data, there
are still 32 million people who have not received access to proper drinking water and 67 million
people do not serve access to proper sanitation (Fauziah & Internasional, 2021). The vital role
of water in daily life is not limited to meeting essential needs only, such as drinking and
bathing. However, it also includes the irrigation needs of agricultural areas, considering that it
also supports water and food security. Thus, in Sustainable Development, Goals 6 set eight
targets, consisting of six main targets and two implementation targets (way of implementation).
The eight targets are outlined in more detail into 29 national indicators. Furthermore, the
government has developed indicators derivatives of the National Medium Term Development
Plan/RPJMN policy 2015 - 2019. RPJMN by the 6th goal of this Sustainable Development
Goals include:
1) Ensure water security through increased knowledge, changes in attitudes and behaviors
in drinking water utilization and sanitation programs;
2) Implementation of synergy of drinking water and sanitation carried out at the national,
provincial, district / city and community levels;
3) Improved effectiveness and efficiency of funding drinking water and sanitation
infrastructure;
4) Maintenance and restoration of water sources and their ecosystems;
5) Fulfillment of needs and guarantee of water quality for daily life for the community;
6) The fulfillment of water needs for productive social and economic needs;
7) Increased community resilience in reducing the risk of water damage including climate
change; and
8) Increased institutional capacity, sustainability, and coherence in integrated, effective,
efficient and sustainable water resource programs, including increased availability and
ease of access to data and information.
Therefore, to overcome this, kaizen methods need to be applied. As already explained, the
Kaizen method emphasizes minor improvements made continuously compared to innovation.
Therefore, there needs to be a strategy in its application. The adoption of the Kaizen method
will be presented in the following figure 3.
Application of the Kaizen Method in Efforts to Maintain the Sustainability of Springs in Indonesia
590 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(5), Feb 2022
Figure 3. Kaizen Method Sustainability Adoption Strategy
Success Indicator
Standardization or success indicators are needed to determine the Kaizen Method's
success. Here are the details of the success indicators:
Figure 4. Success Indicator
CONCLUSION
The Kaizen method is very suitable to be implemented as protection in maintaining the
availability of clean water for the community. The existence of water care with the Kaizen
method is expected to support the realization of SDGs 2030 points 6 and 11. The establishment
of the 5S program in the Kaizen method is being used by companies and can maintain the
spring's sustainability. The program's implementation adheres to the concept prepared using
the house model. There are three components to build promising visions: dream located as the
rooftop; pillar consists as the main methods to achieve this vision and the foundation as the
leading indicators of improved performance and the behavior of supporting factors. In this case,
to maintain the sustainability of springs in Indonesia, a community service program is
implemented with the principle of the Kaizen Kaizen method. For this idea to continue, it is
necessary to adopt the three aspects of society, government, and regulation.
Application of the Kaizen Method in Efforts to Maintain the Sustainability of Springs in Indonesia
591 Interdisciplinary Social Studies, 1(5), Feb 2022
REFERENCES
Al Janahi, Rafid, Zarreh, Alireza, Wan, Hung Da, & Lee, Yooneun. (2019). Implementing
Kaizen through a lean RACE Model: A case study. IISE Annual Conference and Expo
2019, 1–6. https://doi.org/10.31224/osf.io/8sxh9
Atmowardoyo, Haryanto. (2018). Research Methods in TEFL Studies: Descriptive Research,
Case Study, Error Analysis, and R & D. Journal of Language Teaching and Research,
9(1), 197. https://doi.org/10.17507/jltr.0901.25
Carnerud, Daniel, Jaca, Carmen, & Bäckström, Ingela. (2018). Kaizen and continuous
improvement – trends and patterns over 30 years. TQM Journal, 30(4), 371–390.
https://doi.org/10.1108/TQM-03-2018-0037
Fauziah, Atikah, & Internasional, Departemen Hukum. (2021). Prinsip kerjasama
internasional terkait program air bersih ( fresh water ) di indonesia dalam mendukung
tercapainya sustainable development goals/sdgs.
Hasbiah, A. W., & Kurniasih, D. (2019). Analysis of water supply and demand management
in Bandung City Indonesia. IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science,
245(1). https://doi.org/10.1088/1755-1315/245/1/012030
Ismawati, Riva, Rahayu, Rina, & Dewantari, Nuryunita. (2020). Kualitas Mata Air Sembir
untuk Pemenuhan Kebutuhan Air Bersih. Indonesian Journal of Natural Science
Education (IJNSE), 03(1), 252–256.
Jupri, A., Kusuma, K., Hidayat, K., & Purnomo, M. (2015). The Efforts of Spring Conservation
Through Local Wisdom at Lingsar, West Lombok, West Nusa Tenggara, Indonesia.
Journal of Environment and …, 5(6), 98–106.
Maryati, S., & Febriani, Y. T. (2021). Status and challenges of water governance in facing the
water crisis disaster in blora regency, indonesia. IOP Conference Series: Earth and
Environmental Science, 683(1). https://doi.org/10.1088/1755-1315/683/1/012145
Randhawa, Jugraj Singh, & Ahuja, Inderpreet Singh. (2017). 5S – a quality improvement tool
for sustainable performance: literature review and directions. International Journal of
Quality and Reliability Management, 34(3), 334–361. https://doi.org/10.1108/IJQRM-03-
2015-0045
Suryani, Anih Sri. (2020). Pembangunan Air Bersih dan Sanitasi saat Pandemi Covid-19.
Aspirasi: Jurnal Masalah-Masalah Sosial, 11(2), 199–214.
https://doi.org/10.46807/aspirasi.v11i2.1757