The Concept of Criminalization of Judicial Negligence: The Merit System and Decision Evaluation as Judicial Reform
Downloads
The failure of the supervision system and sanctioning mechanisms to address the negligence of judges has created an urgent need to reform the justice system. Disparities in the independence and accountability of judges create accountability gaps in the justice system. This study uses a juridical-normative approach to analyze positive legal norms, legal principles, and the systematics of laws and regulations related to the accountability of judges for negligence in deciding criminal cases. This study reconceptualizes culpa lata into two categories: negligence that leads to KKN, using the Theory of Rational Choice, Theory of Opportunity, and the Theory of White Collar Crime based on motives and manipulation attempts. Non-KKN Negligence, in the first phase, examines the individual level based on Social Control Theory. The second phase analyzes the failure of the supervisory system to function at the institutional level using the Theory of Sociological Institutionalism and the Theory of Rational Choice Institutionalism. The findings suggest that criminalizing culpa lata is a last resort. Therefore, the authors propose an integrated concept consisting of three components: the evaluation of AI-based judgments synergized with the merit system as a tool for detecting negligence, the special court as the final judicial forum, and the criminalization of culpa lata as a sanction mechanism. This concept aims to balance judicial independence with accountability through effective and organized mechanisms in order to restore public trust and realize the role of the Supreme Court in Indonesia.
Antunes, H. S., Freitas, P. M., Oliveira, A. L., pereira, C. M., Sequeira, E. V. de, & Xavier, L. B. (2024). Multidisciplinary Perspectives on Artificial Intelligence and the Law (Vol. 58). Springer International Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-41264-6
Ekayanta, F. B. (2024). Kesinambungan Sistem Proporsional Terbuka Sebagai Sistem Pemilihan Legislatif di Indonesia. POLITIKA: Jurnal Ilmu Politik, 5(2), 3–4.
Fachri, F. K. (2023, Oktober 31). Upaya MA Tingkatkan Konsistensi dan Kualitas Putusan Hakim. Hukum Online.Com. https://www.hukumonline.com/berita/a/upaya-ma-tingkatkan-konsistensi-dan-kualitas-putusan-hakim-lt653ff16dc29d1/
Fatoni, S. (2020). Penghapusan Kriminalisasi terhadap Hakim dan Jaksa dalam Rangka Mewujudkan Sinkronisasi Sistem Peradilan Pidana Anak. jurnalkonstitusi.mkri.id, 17(1), 16–17. https://jurnalkonstitusi.mkri.id/index.php/jk/article/view/17110/pdf
Fine, A., & Marsh, S. (2024). Judicial leadership matters (yet again): the association between judge and public trust for artificial intelligence in courts. Discover Artificial Intelligence, 4(1), 44. https://doi.org/10.1007/s44163-024-00142-3
Ginting Miko. (2023, November 3). KY Usulkan 45 Hakim Dijatuhi Sanksi. Komisiyudisial.go.id. https://komisiyudisial.go.id/frontend/pers_release_detail/304/ky-usulkan-hakim-dijatuhi-sanksi
Gunardi. (2022). Buku Ajar Metode Penelitian Hukum (Murni, Ed.; 1 ed.). Damera Press.
Hairi, P. J. (2014). Kebijakan Kriminalisasi Terhadap Hakim Dalam Rancangan Undang-Undang Tentang Mahkamah Agung. Jurnal.dpr.go.id, 5(1), 13–14. https://jurnal.dpr.go.id/index.php/hukum/article/view/210/151
Indonesian Corruption Watch. (2025). Kasus Suap Hakim 2021-2024.
Komisi Yudisial. (2022). Laporan Tahunan Komisi Yudisial 2021 Memperkuat Sinergitas dalam Rangka Peningkatan Integritas Hakim. https://www.komisiyudisial.go.id/storage/assets/uploads/files/Laporan%20Tahunan/Laporan-Tahunan-KY-2021.pdf
Komisi Yudisial. (2023). Laporan Tahunan Komisi Yudisial 2022 Komisi Yudisial Berakhlak untuk Integritas Hakim. https://komisiyudisial.go.id/storage/assets/uploads/files/Laporan%20Tahunan/Laporan-Tahunan-KY-2022.pdf
Komisi Yudisial. (2024). Laporan Tahunan Komisi Yudisial 2023 Merajut Nusantara untuk Menjaga Integritas Hakim. https://www.komisiyudisial.go.id/storage/assets/uploads/files/Laporan%20Tahunan/Laporan-Tahunan-KY-2023.pdf
Komisi Yudisial Republik Indonesia. (2017). Proceeding Symposium: The Line Between Legal Error and Misconduct of Judges (Ilham.Muhamad, Ed.; 1 ed., Vol. 1). Sekretariat Jenderal Komisi Yudisial Republik Indonesia. https://komisiyudisial.go.id/storage/assets/uploads/files/2ca92-proceeding-symposium-the-line-between-legal-error-and-misconduct-of-judges.pdf
Luthan, S. (2009). Asas dan Kriteria Kriminalisasi. media.neliti.com, 16(1), 1–17. https://media.neliti.com/media/publications/84197-none-b7d388b3.pdf
Marzuki, S., Azhari, A. F., Harijanti, S. D., Wajdi, F., Madril, O., Amsari, F., Arifin, F., Putro, W. D., Djamil, M. N., Nurbaningsih, E., Lumbuun, T. G., Imran, Hidayati, F. R., Parlina, N., & Azhar, I. (2018). Meluruskan Arah Manajemen Kekuasaan Kehakiman (Imran. & F. R. Hidayati, Ed.; 1 ed., Vol. 1). Sekretariat Jenderal Komisi Yudisial Republik Indonesia. https://komisiyudisial.go.id/storage/assets/uploads/files/Buku-Bunga-Rampai-2018.pdf
Marzuki, S., Shidarta, Harijanti, S. D., Imran, Sumampouw, N. E. J., Nuqul, F. L., Riyadi, E., Heryansyah, D., Syarifuddin, H. M., Suharto, Marbun, A. N., Sembiring, R. G., Kartika, D., Nurdin, I., Darmawati, I. G. A. B., Purwanti, Sombolinggi, R., Cahyadi, E., Muchsin, A., & Suprihatiningsih. (2024). Memotret Pertimbangan Putusan Hakim dari Berbagai Perspektif (F. R. Hidayati, Ed.; 1 ed., Vol. 1). Sekretariat Jenderal Komisi Yudisial Republik Indonesia. https://www.komisiyudisial.go.id/storage/assets/uploads/files/aGKnO6sj_Bunga%20Rampai%20isi%20All%20small.pdf
Mochtar, Z. A., & Hiariej, E. O. S. (2021). Dasar-Dasar Ilmu Hukum (1 ed.).
Muhaimin. (2020). Metode Penelitian Hukum (F. Hijriyanti, Ed.; Vol. 1). UPT. MATARAM UNIVERSITY PRESS. https://eprints.unram.ac.id/20305/1/Metode%20Penelitian%20Hukum.pdf
Panjaitan, B. S. (2018). Forum Privilegiatum Sebagai Wujud Peradilan yang Adil Bagi Masyarakat. Media Hukum, 25(1).
Putusan PN Surabaya Nomor 454/Pid.B/2024/PN Sby (24 Juli 2024). https://putusan3.mahkamahagung.go.id/direktori/putusan/zaef4e120aad420088da303832313236.html
Risnain, M. (2018). Kriminalisasi Hakim dan Eksistensi Prinsip Judicial Independence Dalam Bingkai Negara Hukum. Jurnal Hukum dan Peradilan, 2(3), 325. https://doi.org/10.25216/jhp.2.3.2013.325-336
Susanti, E., & Rahardjo, E. (2018). Hukum dan Kriminologi (H. SIswanto, Ed.; Siswanto, Heni). Cv. Anugrah Utama Raharja. https://jdih.situbondokab.go.id/barang/buku/Hukum%20dan%20Kriminologi%20Buku%20Ajar%20(Emilia%20Susanti,%20S.H.,%20M.H.%20%20Eko%20Rahadjo,%20S.H.%20etc.)%20(z-lib.org).pdf
Tim Advokasi Anti Penyiksaan (TAP). (2022, April 26). Salah Tangkap Fikry Cs.: Hakim Melanggengkan Penyiksaan. bantuanhukum.or.id.
Valerian, D. (2022). Kriteria Kriminalisasi: Analisis Pemikiran Moeljatno, Sudarto, Theo De Roos, dan iris Haenen. Veritas et Justitia, 8(2), 415–443. https://doi.org/10.25123/vej.v8i2.4923
Wahyuni, F. (2017). Dasar-Dasar Hukum Pidana Di Indonesia (Azmi. M Rizqi, Ed.; 1 ed., Vol. 1). PT Nusantara Persada Utama. https://jdih.situbondokab.go.id/barang/buku/Dasar-Dasar%20Hukum%20Pidana%20di%20Indonesia%20by%20Dr.%20Fitri%20Wahyuni.,%20S.H.,%20M.H.%20(z-lib.org).pdf
Widiarty, W. S. (2024). Buku Ajar Metode Penelitian Hukum (M. Tajuddin, Ed.; 1 ed.). Publika Global Media.
Copyright (c) 2025 Robert Febriyanto Turnip, Maman Budiman

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
- Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International. that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work.


